{ "release": "5.70", "sourceGeneratedAt": "2026-09-03T11:11:41Z", "sourcePath": "assets/data/certification-summary.json", "review": "Internal published results; not rerun against a city database in this website release.", "cities": { "lagos": { "demographics": { "name": "Demographics", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "demographics", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 39, "pass": 35, "fail": 0, "warn": 1, "info": 0, "na": 3, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "DEMO-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dbo.Citizen volume: 26387378", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizen.DOB in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizen registration date must not precede date of birth (RegistrationDate < DOB): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Duplicate non-NULL Citizen.NationalId values: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C05", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Household.HeadCitizenId genuinely orphaned or unsynced (excludes legitimate foreign-national-headed NULLs): N/A (no HeadCitizenI", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HouseholdMember.CitizenId not found in dbo.Citizen: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Birth.BirthDate does not match Citizen.DOB for the same CitizenId: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Death.DeathDate <= own Citizen.DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Death.DeathDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Birth.MotherCitizenId under 12 years old at the recorded BirthDate: 0 of 4687303 linked births", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Migration.MigrationDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Migration.MigrationDate before own Citizen.DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C13", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Not-dissolved households whose current CITIZEN Head has no matching Household.HeadCitizenId (excludes dissolved households and foreign-national heads -- see comment): N/A (no HeadCitizenI", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.PopulationSnapshot volume: 22620", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TwoParent=1824810 (26.6%), SingleMother=1473699 (21.5%), SingleFather=1589913 (23.2%), ChildHeaded=0 (0.0%), Extended=70266 (1.0%), SinglePerson=1597213 (23.3%), Other=295670 (4.3%), of 6851571 households -- 0 child-headed households of 6,851,571 current households (0.00%). ChildHeaded is a measurement only, not a hard-zero requirement -- see DEMO-C22/C23/C24/C27 for the actual structural invariants (all of which DO assert hard zero); a nonzero residual here reflects this database's own current lineage + placement model coverage, not a certification failure by itself.", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "% of 80+ birth cohort marked dead: 58.70% of 193548 (floor 15%, regression guard for the one-time-roll mortality bug)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with zero current household memberships: 0; citizens with 2+ current memberships (constraint violation): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with 2+ current Spouse-role members: 0; HouseholdMember rows with LeaveDate < JoinDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Dissolved households with current members: 0; empty-but-not-marked-dissolved households (informational, not failed on): 165; DissolutionDate/IsActive mismatches: N/A (no IsActive col", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C20", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens whose Nth household transition starts before their (N-1)th one ended: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C21", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HouseholdMember rows with JoinDate before the member's own DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C22", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Minor Head with an eligible non-Lodger adult present in the same household: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C23", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with a real current member (citizen or foreign national) but no current Head: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C24", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with more than one current Head: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C25", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ChildCarePlacement rows with PlacementDate before the placed citizen's own DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C26", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Current HouseholdMember rows with neither CitizenId nor ForeignNationalId populated: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C27", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with more than one ACTIVE CHILD_HEADED placement: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C28", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "Households typed 'Single' with more than 1 current member: 23231 (known pre-existing HouseholdType staleness, broader than Tier 4 -- see this check's own comment)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C29", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households whose ordinary (non-emergency) FORCED_ABSORPTION placements alone exceed the size-25 soft cap: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C30", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Households over the size-25 soft cap lacking an explicit FORCED_ABSORPTION_EMERGENCY placement reason: 0 of 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C31", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households over the group-concentration-8 soft cap without an explicit emergency placement reason: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Males per 100 females: 105.82 (M=13566951, F=12820423; real populations run ~103-107 at birth). Root cause of any deviation traced to cal.PopulationPyramid seed data itself, not just generator logic -- see CHANGELOG for detail; not fixed here (control-DB scope).", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Crude birth rate (trailing 12mo births per 1,000 living-population-proxy): 34.06 (898775 births; sourced band 20-40 per UN WPP 2022 Kenya~28.3/Nigeria~34.2)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Crude death rate (trailing 12mo deaths per 1,000 living-population-proxy): 6.65 (175365 deaths; sourced band 3-15 per UN WPP 2022 Kenya~5.4/Nigeria~11.4)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct CauseCategory values: 6; largest bucket: 34.96% of 2308232 deaths", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct MigrationType values represented: 3 of 3 (In/Out/Internal), across 2000000 rows", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Migration In=599576 vs Out=400936 (both cities are real net-in-migration urban destinations; In should be >= Out)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with DOB in the older half of the observed date range: 1599435 vs younger half: 24787943 (a growing population should skew toward the younger/more-recent half)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Mean live household size: 3.52 (24118246 live members / 6851571 households; sourced band 1.5-7.0 per KNBS 2019 Nairobi~2.9 / Nigeria NDHS~4.8-5.0)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/demographics-certification.html" }, "household": { "name": "Households", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "demographics", "sourceShared": true, "result": { "total": 39, "pass": 35, "fail": 0, "warn": 1, "info": 0, "na": 3, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "DEMO-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dbo.Citizen volume: 26387378", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizen.DOB in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizen registration date must not precede date of birth (RegistrationDate < DOB): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Duplicate non-NULL Citizen.NationalId values: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C05", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Household.HeadCitizenId genuinely orphaned or unsynced (excludes legitimate foreign-national-headed NULLs): N/A (no HeadCitizenI", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HouseholdMember.CitizenId not found in dbo.Citizen: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Birth.BirthDate does not match Citizen.DOB for the same CitizenId: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Death.DeathDate <= own Citizen.DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Death.DeathDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Birth.MotherCitizenId under 12 years old at the recorded BirthDate: 0 of 4687303 linked births", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Migration.MigrationDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Migration.MigrationDate before own Citizen.DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C13", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Not-dissolved households whose current CITIZEN Head has no matching Household.HeadCitizenId (excludes dissolved households and foreign-national heads -- see comment): N/A (no HeadCitizenI", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.PopulationSnapshot volume: 22620", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TwoParent=1824810 (26.6%), SingleMother=1473699 (21.5%), SingleFather=1589913 (23.2%), ChildHeaded=0 (0.0%), Extended=70266 (1.0%), SinglePerson=1597213 (23.3%), Other=295670 (4.3%), of 6851571 households -- 0 child-headed households of 6,851,571 current households (0.00%). ChildHeaded is a measurement only, not a hard-zero requirement -- see DEMO-C22/C23/C24/C27 for the actual structural invariants (all of which DO assert hard zero); a nonzero residual here reflects this database's own current lineage + placement model coverage, not a certification failure by itself.", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "% of 80+ birth cohort marked dead: 58.70% of 193548 (floor 15%, regression guard for the one-time-roll mortality bug)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with zero current household memberships: 0; citizens with 2+ current memberships (constraint violation): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with 2+ current Spouse-role members: 0; HouseholdMember rows with LeaveDate < JoinDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Dissolved households with current members: 0; empty-but-not-marked-dissolved households (informational, not failed on): 165; DissolutionDate/IsActive mismatches: N/A (no IsActive col", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C20", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens whose Nth household transition starts before their (N-1)th one ended: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C21", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HouseholdMember rows with JoinDate before the member's own DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C22", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Minor Head with an eligible non-Lodger adult present in the same household: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C23", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with a real current member (citizen or foreign national) but no current Head: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C24", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with more than one current Head: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C25", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ChildCarePlacement rows with PlacementDate before the placed citizen's own DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C26", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Current HouseholdMember rows with neither CitizenId nor ForeignNationalId populated: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C27", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with more than one ACTIVE CHILD_HEADED placement: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C28", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "Households typed 'Single' with more than 1 current member: 23231 (known pre-existing HouseholdType staleness, broader than Tier 4 -- see this check's own comment)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C29", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households whose ordinary (non-emergency) FORCED_ABSORPTION placements alone exceed the size-25 soft cap: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C30", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Households over the size-25 soft cap lacking an explicit FORCED_ABSORPTION_EMERGENCY placement reason: 0 of 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C31", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households over the group-concentration-8 soft cap without an explicit emergency placement reason: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Males per 100 females: 105.82 (M=13566951, F=12820423; real populations run ~103-107 at birth). Root cause of any deviation traced to cal.PopulationPyramid seed data itself, not just generator logic -- see CHANGELOG for detail; not fixed here (control-DB scope).", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Crude birth rate (trailing 12mo births per 1,000 living-population-proxy): 34.06 (898775 births; sourced band 20-40 per UN WPP 2022 Kenya~28.3/Nigeria~34.2)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Crude death rate (trailing 12mo deaths per 1,000 living-population-proxy): 6.65 (175365 deaths; sourced band 3-15 per UN WPP 2022 Kenya~5.4/Nigeria~11.4)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct CauseCategory values: 6; largest bucket: 34.96% of 2308232 deaths", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct MigrationType values represented: 3 of 3 (In/Out/Internal), across 2000000 rows", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Migration In=599576 vs Out=400936 (both cities are real net-in-migration urban destinations; In should be >= Out)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with DOB in the older half of the observed date range: 1599435 vs younger half: 24787943 (a growing population should skew toward the younger/more-recent half)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Mean live household size: 3.52 (24118246 live members / 6851571 households; sourced band 1.5-7.0 per KNBS 2019 Nairobi~2.9 / Nigeria NDHS~4.8-5.0)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/household-certification.html" }, "education": { "name": "Education", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "education", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 22, "pass": 19, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 3, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "EDU-H01", "name": "Schools populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "school count=1702 (min 100)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H02", "name": "Enrollment.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H03", "name": "Teacher.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H04", "name": "Student age at enrollment plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-band rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H05", "name": "EnrollmentDate within SeedEpoch..NowDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H06", "name": "Exam scores in [0,100]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H07", "name": "Bursary amount > 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "non-positive rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H08", "name": "Teacher licence-number uniqueness", "status": "PASS", "detail": "duplicate licence numbers=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H09", "name": "TertiaryEnrollment end year >= start year", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H10", "name": "Every populated ward has an active school", "status": "PASS", "detail": "uncovered populated wards=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H11", "name": "Attendance date >= Enrollment start", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violating rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H12", "name": "TertiaryInstitution.WardId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H13", "name": "StudentPopulation.UniversityId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "enrollment rows with age outside their GradeLevel's plausible band=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "employed 25-34yr-olds with an Enrollment record=100.00% (KNBS NEMIS cites 82% school-enrollment ages 6-17; NBF R-03 ref=80%, band 50-100%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "latest fully-generated AcademicYear=2025, max deviation from LSMOE-2022 age-band citation=2.35pp (band <=15pp)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R04", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Kenya-only check (secondary-tier pyramid is a Kenya-specific structure)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rows with an implausible program length for their ProgramType=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R06", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "measurement only -- pupil:teacher ratio=0.00:1 -- no cited real pupil-teacher-ratio target exists for either city yet", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-C01", "name": "Historical academic-year coverage", "status": "N/A", "detail": "expected years (1960-2026)=67, generated years=66 (98.51%), earliest=1960, latest=2025, fully-generated=65, partially-generated=1 (the single oldest generated year, 1960, is the only one that can be partial -- see check header)", "source": "11_coverage_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-C02", "name": "Grade/progression coverage completeness", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Expected grade-year cells=1056, SATISFIED=1056, EXHAUSTED_VARIANCE=0, INCOMPLETE=0, EXHAUSTED_ANOMALY=0, missing terminal-secondary cells=0 (exhaustion state from RunId A15FF2B7-DB4F-4C97-88C4-4E1F7FA89DCC)", "source": "11_coverage_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-C02b", "name": "Examination/TertiaryEnrollment dependency guards", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Terminal-secondary Enrollment=22993166 -> Examination terminal rows=122990; tertiary-eligible Examination rows=85945 -> TertiaryEnrollment rows=17631", "source": "11_coverage_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/education-certification.html" }, "employment": { "name": "Employment", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "employment", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 49, "pass": 43, "fail": 2, "warn": 2, "info": 1, "na": 1, "failChecks": [ { "code": "EMP-E32", "detail": "Active Contract rows holding a credentialed title with no matching completed TertiaryEnrollment: 3636" }, { "code": "EMP-E33", "detail": "Active Contract rows whose title requires a professional license with no matching active ProfessionalLicense: 97" } ], "checks": [ { "code": "EMP-E01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Employer volume: 10002", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Department volume: 43473 (expected >= 4x Employer)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract volume: 1384970", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SelfEmployment volume: 3469421", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Payroll volume: 8043728", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.CitizenId FK violations: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SelfEmployment.CitizenId FK violations: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows for deceased citizens: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.StartDate outside [DOB+18, NowDate]: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.EndDate < StartDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.IsActive/Termination-row mismatches: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with both active Contract and active SelfEmployment: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Payroll rows with GrossAmount<=0 or NetAmount<0: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Termination.TerminationDate < Contract.StartDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct SectorCode in Employer: 16 (expected >= 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EmploymentEventIndex populated: 87 years", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SelfEmployment.StartDate outside [DOB+18, NowDate]: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.StartDate after own citizen DeathDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "% of citizens who died at age 25+ with any employment history (Contract or SelfEmployment): 33.47% of 1532470 (floor 25%, regression guard for the blanket demographics.Death exclusion pattern)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E20", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Payroll pay-period after Contract.EndDate month: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E21", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Payroll pay-period after citizen DeathDate month: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E22", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PensionContribution period after Contract.EndDate month: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E23", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PensionContribution period after citizen DeathDate month: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E24", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.DepartmentId belonging to a different EmployerId: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E25", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows whose Department slot is not an active mapped choice for JobTitleId: 0 (0 historical/inactive rows preserved as a disclosed pre-Phase-E department-taxonomy artifact, not counted toward this check)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E26", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "JobTitleCatalog titles with no active JobTitleDepartmentMap row: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E27", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract rows whose own non-NULL JobTitleId has no currently-active department mapping: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E28", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "City/Sector cells where active Deployment total exceeds active Participation PAY_WAGE total: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E29", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows whose Department is not applicable for its Employer's Sector+Size template: 0 (0 historical/inactive rows reported separately, non-gating)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E31", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows whose current-role effective date (ContractRoleHistory/PromotionHistory/StartDate) is still below SeniorityProgressionRule's age floor for their current SeniorityLevel: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E32", "name": "", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "Active Contract rows holding a credentialed title with no matching completed TertiaryEnrollment: 3636", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E33", "name": "", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "Active Contract rows whose title requires a professional license with no matching active ProfessionalLicense: 97", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E34", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows holding an active ProfessionalLicense not in that title's allowed profession set: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E35", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Nairobi job families proven materially reachable by H0's shadow diagnostic (AGRO/EDUJ/ENGG/FNAC/HRES) with zero live active representation: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E36", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows below the applicable StatutoryWageFloor: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E37", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Within-family seniority coherence (min-vs-max populated level, both >=10 contracts, 10% overlap tolerance): 0 of 13 tested families materially inverted", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E38", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Within-occupation EmployerSize salary ratio: avg=1.6115 max=3.3447", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E39", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Largest exact-value point mass in active GrossMonthlyLocal: 1930 of 1191037", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E40", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract/Payroll gross mismatches=0, Payroll arithmetic mismatches=0, Payroll/Pension mismatches=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E41", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contracts under a LIQUIDATED employer (should be 0, closed by usp_CloseLiquidatedEmployerContracts): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E42", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Active Contracts under a DORMANT/SUSPENDED employer (informational -- no auto-termination policy defined yet): 175081", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-EDU-001", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "Avg JobTitleCatalog.SeniorityLevel: degree-holders=2.37, no education record at all=2.40 (EMP-00007 causal link)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-EDU-002", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "Of 50466 active SeniorityLevel>=4 contracts, 0.54% held by a citizen with a COMPLETED tertiary program (sourced floor 40%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-EDU-003", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Formal-employment rate: no-education-record=10.23% (n=43162), completed-tertiary=41.61% (n=5271)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct EmploymentType values: 3 across 1384970 contracts", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active contracts below the minimum wage (NGN 70,000/month, Nigeria National Minimum Wage 2024): 0.00% of 1191037 (sourced ceiling 15%% -- some sub-minimum-wage employment is realistic, a majority would not be)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "GrossMonthlyLocal range: min=70000.00, avg=137831.72, max=2456799.12", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with both an active Contract and a SelfEmployment record: 0 of 3469421 self-employed", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct JobTitleId values in use: 53 of 58 cataloged (JobTitleCatalog is under-utilized by the generator -- disclosed, not fixed this pass)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/employment-certification.html" }, "health": { "name": "Health", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "health", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 86, "pass": 47, "fail": 8, "warn": 3, "info": 2, "na": 26, "failChecks": [ { "code": "HLT-REL01", "detail": "Scoped to ENCOUNTER-type prescriptions only -- REFILL-type has no single anchoring visit by design." }, { "code": "HLT-REL02", "detail": "Population-level General-Surgery/Orthopedic draws (SourceICD10Code IS NULL) are out of scope by design." }, { "code": "HLT-REL03", "detail": "A general-screening lab with no condition-driven indication would legitimately fail this -- interpret alongside population share, not as an absolute gate, if it ever fires on real data." }, { "code": "HLT-REL05", "detail": "This is the known, previously-disclosed Emergency/MCH facility-capability gap (COMMERCIAL_RELEASE_SCOPING.md) -- expected to genuinely FAIL on first real data, not a new finding." }, { "code": "HLT-REL06", "detail": "Scoped to REFILL-type only -- the corrected generator population, not the disclosed pre-fix 157.66M-row historical population (see CHANGELOG HLT-00040/health/core/06_growth.sql header)." }, { "code": "HLT-REL08", "detail": "Only checks allergies identified BEFORE the prescribing visit -- a later-discovered allergy does not retroactively indict an earlier, reasonable prescription." }, { "code": "HLT-SPEC05", "detail": "LabResult rows without SpecimenId=27221873" }, { "code": "HLT-RXD04", "detail": "IsDispensed=1 Prescription rows=127652943" } ], "stale": true, "staleReason": "Lagos Health cannot be safely re-certified while LGSDB_12_HealthBatchDriver (a live full health-generation rebuild, started 2026-09-01 17:13, still running as of this publish) is actively writing to the same tables. As of the last check: core clinical tables substantially populated (Prescription 179.5M, Visit 42.7M, Condition 25.4M rows and growing); MedicationDispense/Symptom/CarePlan/CareTeam/Imaging/PatientDevice tables still at zero, not yet started. These 8 FAIL entries reflect a pre-rebuild snapshot, not current state -- re-run once the rebuild completes." }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/health-certification.html" }, "hr": { "name": "HR", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "hr", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 22, "pass": 22, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "HR-H01", "name": "employment.Job populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "job count=261 (min 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H02", "name": "employment.Job: MinSalaryLocal <= MaxSalaryLocal", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H03", "name": "employment.Job: All salaries > 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "zero/negative salary rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H04", "name": "employment.Job: JobCode unique", "status": "PASS", "detail": "duplicate JobCodes=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H05", "name": "employment.Job: GradeLevel in valid set", "status": "PASS", "detail": "invalid grade rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H06", "name": "employment.Job: Sector in valid set", "status": "PASS", "detail": "invalid sector rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H07", "name": "employment.Job: At least 10 distinct sectors", "status": "PASS", "detail": "distinct sectors=25 (min 10)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H08", "name": "employment.Job: Entry-level jobs present", "status": "PASS", "detail": "entry-level job count=45 (min 10)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H09", "name": "hr.Employee populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "employee count=1,191,037", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H10", "name": "hr.Employee.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned employee rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H11", "name": "hr.Payroll: NetAmount <= GrossAmount", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H12", "name": "hr.SocialInsuranceScheme: Health and Pension schemes seeded", "status": "PASS", "detail": "health schemes=1, pension schemes=1", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H13", "name": "hr.GradeTierMap covers all GradeBands used by hr.Position", "status": "PASS", "detail": "unmapped grade bands=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H14", "name": "hr.Payroll: no rows after Employee.SeparationDateUtc", "status": "PASS", "detail": "payroll rows after separation=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H15", "name": "hr.Payroll: deduction pass evidence (NetAmount < GrossAmount)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "deducted rows=99,080,411 of 99,080,411 -- 0 suggests usp_ApplyHrPayrollDeductions has not run", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H16", "name": "hr.Payroll rows after the employee's own citizen DeathDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "post-death payroll rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H17", "name": "% of citizens who died at age 25+ with any hr.Employee history", "status": "PASS", "detail": "measurement only (HR participation is a small public-sector subset, not universal): 0 of 1532470", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Payroll rows where NetAmount != Gross-PAYE-Health-Pension (within 1.0): 0 of 99080411", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Average PAYE effective rate: 15.95% of gross (sourced band 5-30%%, Nigeria progressive PAYE bands to 24%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Average pension deduction rate: 7.09% of gross (sourced band 1-10%%, Nigeria Contributory Pension Scheme, 8%% employee contribution)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Average health insurance deduction rate: 4.43% of gross (sourced band 0.5-5%%, Nigeria NHIS ~5%% employee contribution)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct PayrollMonth values: 648", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/hr-certification.html" }, "civil-registration": { "name": "Civil Registration", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "civil-registration", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/civil-registration-certification.html" }, "economy": { "name": "Economy", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "economy", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/economy-certification.html" }, "business": { "name": "Business", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "business", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 17, "pass": 16, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 1, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "BIZ-01", "name": "business.SectorCrosswalk populated (16 canonical sectors)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rows=16", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-02", "name": "dbo.Business populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "business count=822190", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-03", "name": "BusinessCode uniqueness", "status": "PASS", "detail": "duplicate codes=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-04", "name": "Business.SectorCode within converged CHECK enum", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-05", "name": "Business.SectorCode resolves in business.SectorCrosswalk", "status": "PASS", "detail": "unmapped=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-06", "name": "Business.OwnerCitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned owner refs=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-07", "name": "Business.RegistrationDate not in the future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future-dated rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-08", "name": "Business.EmployeeCount within its BusinessSize band", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-09", "name": "transport.Operator.BusinessId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned operator refs=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-10", "name": "No non-liquidated business owned by a deceased citizen", "status": "PASS", "detail": "non-liquidated businesses with deceased owner=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-11", "name": "No owner exceeds the per-owner business cap", "status": "PASS", "detail": "worst single-owner business count=5, cap=5", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "RegistrationDate before OwnerCitizenId.DOB: 0; owner under 18 at registration: 0 of 566598 owned businesses. Real root cause was usp_ReweightForeignOriginBusinessOwnership reassigning owners with no DOB/age eligibility check, not stale pre-fix data as BUS-00002 originally assumed -- fixed + backfilled + guarded by a DOB/Death trigger on dbo.Business, see CHANGELOG BUS-00003.", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "MICRO=54.97% SMALL=29.99% MEDIUM=10.06% (sourced target 55/30/10 per CAC/NBS 2023 Lagos State Business Survey, +-5pp band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct SectorCode values: 16 of 16; largest sector: 22.02% of 822190 businesses", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EmployeeCount > 1 but IsEmployer = 0: 0 of 822190 businesses", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R05", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Foreign-owned businesses: 7802 (0.95%) of 822190 -- no cited city-level benchmark, reporting only", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ACTIVE businesses: 80.03% of 822190 (some DORMANT/SUSPENDED/LIQUIDATED expected, not 100% active)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/business-certification.html" }, "banking": { "name": "Banking", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "banking", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/banking-certification.html" }, "finance": { "name": "Finance", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "finance", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 22, "pass": 19, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 3, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "FIN-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxType volume: 8", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BudgetHead volume: 18", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAccount orphaned Citizen/Business FKs: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAccount rows violating exactly-one-owner: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAssessment orphaned Account/Type FKs: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAssessment negative amounts / DueDate < AssessmentDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAssessment orphaned ParcelId FKs: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxPayment orphaned FK / non-positive amount: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BudgetAllocation orphaned FK / negative amount: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BudgetExpenditure orphaned FK / non-positive amount: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BudgetAllocation rows with cumulative overspend: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Directorate volume: 9", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Department orphaned DirectorateId FKs: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DepartmentWorkforceWeight sum: 10000 (expected 10000bp)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAssessment rows with invalid Status: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxPayment.PaymentDate before its Assessment.AssessmentDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active TaxAccount under a LIQUIDATED business (should be 0): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R01", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Tax assessments with at least one payment: 64.09% of 38325462 -- no cited real-world tax-compliance-rate benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 30-98% PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R02", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Budget utilization (BudgetExpenditure / BudgetAllocation.ApprovedAmount): 83.44% -- no cited real-world budget-utilization-rate benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 50-100% PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct TaxTypeId values on TaxAssessment: 8", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAccount by CitizenId: 710558; by BusinessId: 822190 of 1532748", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R05", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Reversed payments: 2.00% of 24562176 -- no cited real-world payment-reversal-rate benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 0-10% PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/finance-certification.html" }, "insurance": { "name": "Insurance", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "insurance", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 16, "pass": 1, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 15, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "INS-01", "name": "InsuranceCompany populated", "status": "N/A", "detail": "no extension has seeded InsuranceCompany yet in this environment", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-02", "name": "Policy catalog populated", "status": "N/A", "detail": "no extension has seeded Policy yet in this environment", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-03", "name": "Coverage.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Coverage is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-04", "name": "Claim amounts non-negative", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Claim is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-05", "name": "Policy.LaunchDate >= InsuranceCompany.EstablishedDate", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Policy is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-06", "name": "Coverage.StartUtc >= Policy.LaunchDate (INS-HIST-001)", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Coverage is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-07", "name": "Coverage.StartUtc >= ops.Config SeedEpoch", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Coverage is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-08", "name": "Claim.SubmittedUtc >= Coverage.StartUtc", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Claim is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-09", "name": "Claim.ProcessedUtc >= Claim.SubmittedUtc", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Claim is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-10", "name": "Claim.IncidentDate <= Claim.SubmittedUtc", "status": "N/A", "detail": "no claims populate IncidentDate in this environment", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-11", "name": "PremiumPayment: Amount >= 0 and (Coverage,Year,Month) unique", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.PremiumPayment is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-12", "name": "Claim: FraudFlag set iff OriginalClaimAmount set", "status": "N/A", "detail": "no claims populate OriginalClaimAmount in this environment (kenya fraud-injection has not run)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-13", "name": "Beneficiary.SharePct in [0,100]", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Beneficiary not present or empty (nigeria extension not active)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-14", "name": "AccidentClaim.AccidentId FK integrity", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.AccidentClaim empty or transport.Accident not yet deployed", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-15", "name": "PremiumPayment/Claim dated after the covered citizen's own DeathDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "post-death premium rows=0, post-death claim rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-R00", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Coverage is empty -- this city's generator has not run yet", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/insurance-certification.html" }, "commerce": { "name": "Commerce", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "commerce", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/commerce-certification.html" }, "hospitality": { "name": "Hospitality", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "hospitality", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/hospitality-certification.html" }, "manufacturing": { "name": "Manufacturing", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "manufacturing", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/manufacturing-certification.html" }, "agriculture": { "name": "Agriculture", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "agriculture", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/agriculture-certification.html" }, "housing": { "name": "Housing", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "housing", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 21, "pass": 20, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 1, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "housing-H01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HousingUnit volume (2600000 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Tenancy volume (6851571 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "RentPayment.AmountLocal all > 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Tenancy.StartDate within [SeedEpoch, NowDate]", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "RentPayment.PeriodMonth in [1,12]", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Eviction.NoticeDate >= Tenancy.StartDate", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Inspection.Outcome all valid catalog values", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "every ward with a citizen has >=1 housing unit", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "AffordableHousingProject unit-count consistency (Occupied<=Allocated<=Target)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Tenancy.MonthlyRentLocal all >= 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HousingType diversity (8 distinct values)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TenureType diversity (6 distinct values)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HousingEventIndex populated (87 years)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "chronology invariants hold (unit/tenancy/inspection/payment ordering)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Inspection.InspectionCode all valid catalog values", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "no open Tenancy for an all-deceased household", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Occupied units (open tenancy): 64.70% of 2600000 housing units", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Rental tenancies: 4316488 vs Owner: 1370316 of 6851571 (both cities are real renter-majority urban markets; rental should be >= owner)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R03", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Evictions: 2.94% of 6851571 tenancies -- no cited real-world eviction-rate benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 0-25% PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct Inspection.Outcome values: 5 across 90476079 inspections", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "AffordableHousingProject allocation: 69.29% of target units across 150 projects", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/housing-certification.html" }, "land": { "name": "Land", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "land", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 20, "pass": 19, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 1, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "LND-L01", "name": "Parcels populated (min 50/ward)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "parcels=77,976 (min 13,000 = 260 wards x 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L02", "name": "Parcel.CitizenOwnerId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned citizen parcels=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L03", "name": "Parcel.BusinessOwnerId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned business parcels=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L04", "name": "No parcel has both CitizenOwnerId and BusinessOwnerId", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dual-owner parcels=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L05", "name": "Parcel.PlotSizeSqM > 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L06", "name": "Parcel.MarketValueLocal >= 0 (where populated)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L07", "name": "Each parcel has an InitialGrant ownership record", "status": "PASS", "detail": "parcels missing initial grant=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L08", "name": "OwnershipHistory.TransactionDate within epoch–NowDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0 [1940-01-01 – 2026-07-02]", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L09", "name": "LandTaxBill.BillAmountLocal > 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L10", "name": "Ward coverage >= 95% of wards have parcels", "status": "PASS", "detail": "wards with parcels=260 of 260", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Parcels still owned by a deceased CitizenOwnerId: 0 of 77976", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct LandUseType values: 6; largest: 38.88% of 77976 parcels", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Correlation(ward IncomeMultiplier, avg parcel MarketValueLocal): 0.761 (directional only -- wealthier wards should show higher land values)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "IsEncumbered=1: 8.00% of 77976 parcels", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "IsServiced rate: Freehold/Leasehold=90.01% vs Informal/Disputed=29.98% (formal tenure should be more serviced)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "OwnershipHistory rows with EndDate before TransactionDate: 0 of 83462", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R07", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "This city's IsEncumbered rate (see LND-R04) should be compared against the other city's own run -- both should show a non-zero, non-trivial rate, not one flat at 0%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Correlation(PlotSizeSqM, MarketValueLocal): 0.46904 across 77976 parcels (directional only -- bigger plots should be worth more, sublinearly)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Most common TransferValueLocal/MarketValueLocal ratio (4dp) accounts for 1.29% of 5486 Sale rows (a real negotiated-price distribution should not concentrate on one exact ratio)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Owner-lives-in-same-ward rate: 36.065% of 54510 individually-owned parcels vs random baseline 0.385% (1/260 wards) -- should be clearly above baseline, not statistically indistinguishable from it", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/land-certification.html" }, "construction": { "name": "Construction", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "construction", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 25, "pass": 25, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "construction-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ProjectSector seeded (2 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ProjectType seeded (39 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit volume (2000 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit.PermitFeeLocal all >= 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit temporal order (ApprovalDate >= ApplicationDate)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project volume (2001 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project CompletedUnits within [0, PlannedUnits]", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SiteInspection volume (2000 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit.ContractorBusinessId FK integrity", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SiteInspection PASS rate plausible (50.0%)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project PlannedEndDate > StartDate", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit approval rate plausible (50.0%)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "every phased project has exactly 4 phases", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ConstructionEventIndex populated (87 years)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "OccupancyCertificate only issued against Completed projects", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SiteInspection.InspectionDate not before linked Project.StartDate/Permit.ApprovalDate", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit.ContractorBusinessId sector coherence (SectorCode=CONSTRUCTION)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project.ContractorBusinessId sector coherence (SectorCode=CONSTRUCTION)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit contractor existed by ApplicationDate (RegistrationDate <= ApplicationDate)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C20", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project contractor existed by StartDate (RegistrationDate <= StartDate)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Completed projects finishing after PlannedEndDate: 73.21% of 601 (real construction/infrastructure projects run late far more often than not -- 0% or near-0% is a generator artifact, not realism)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Avg ActualCostLocal/BudgetLocal ratio: 1.100; % over budget: 68.55% (sourced band: ratio 1.0-1.3, >=50% over-budget, per global infrastructure cost-overrun literature)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct ProjectTypeId values used: 39; largest single type: 2.65% of 2001 projects", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct construction.Project.Status values: 4 of up to 4 (Planned/Active/Completed/Suspended)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct SiteInspection.Outcome values: 4 across 2000 inspections", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/construction-certification.html" }, "infrastructure": { "name": "Infrastructure", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "infrastructure", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/infrastructure-certification.html" }, "urban-planning": { "name": "Urban Planning", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "urban-planning", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/urban-planning-certification.html" }, "real-estate": { "name": "Real Estate", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "real-estate", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/real-estate-certification.html" }, "transport": { "name": "Transport", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "transport", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 42, "pass": 39, "fail": 0, "warn": 1, "info": 2, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "TR-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Operator volume: 600", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Route volume: 99", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle volume: 1071", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip volume: 24800520", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "AccidentParticipant.Role values outside catalog (casing regression guard): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle.OperatorId FK violations: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip.ArrivalUtc < DepartureUtc: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle assigned to a Route owned by a different Operator: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle.AcquiredDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Ticket.DueDate < IssuedDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Accident.ReportedToPolice=1 with no PoliceReportNumber: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "AccidentClaim.AccidentId FK violations: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DriverLicense.ExpiryDate <= IssuedDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Fare.BoardingStageId = AlightingStageId: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip.DepartureUtc after driver's own DeathDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TransportEventIndex populated: 87 years", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip.PassengerCount > Vehicle.SeatCapacity: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle.YearOfManufacture > YEAR(AcquiredDate): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DriverLicense.IssuedDate before holder's 18th birthday: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C20", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "LicenseRenewal.RenewalDate before original license IssuedDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C21", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TicketPayment.AmountPaidLocal > Ticket.FineAmountLocal: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C22", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip.DepartureUtc after Vehicle.RetiredDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV01", "name": "PrivateVehicle populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicle count=1010668 (min 1000)", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV02", "name": "OwnerType coverage (need >=5 of 7)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "distinct OwnerType=7", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV03", "name": "Owner-shape integrity (exactly one owner link per OwnerType)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV04", "name": "OwnerCitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned rows=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV05", "name": "OwnerBusinessId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned rows=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV06", "name": "OwnerForeignNationalId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned rows=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV07", "name": "PlateNumber uniqueness", "status": "PASS", "detail": "duplicate plate groups=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV08", "name": "YearOfManufacture in [1980, NowYear]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV09", "name": "RegistrationDate <= NowDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV10", "name": "Second-vehicle rate plausible (2%-25% of individual owners)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rate=12.06% (97214 of 806147 individual owners)", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "year=2025 trips/active-vehicle/day=5.860 (1868388 trips / 873 active vehicles) -- design target 6-10/day per kenya/06_growth.sql, corroborated by Lagos danfo field research (~9.2/day)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R02", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "active in 2025=873 of 1071 ever-registered (1071 not yet retired as of NowDate) -- no fixed target, fleet turnover expected", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "avg occupancy%% peak=74.01 midday=36.42 off-peak=9.76", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R04", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "Lagos danfo peak target >=100%% (real danfos routinely carry 100-150%% of seats -- LAMATA/Lagos transport-plan data, Agbiboa 2023, Bjorkegren et al.) got=74.0; midday=36.4 off-peak=9.8 (no cited Lagos time-of-day breakdown -- reported, not scored)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "min=186 avg=2140.19 max=2190 trips/vehicle in 2025", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "revenue-with-no-passengers=0, passengers-with-no-revenue=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R07", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "modeled fleet=1071 -- no independently-cited absolute Lagos danfo fleet count in this codebase; available research gives modal share instead: danfos ~45.5%% of all Lagos vehicles, ~9.98M passenger-trips/day citywide (2015 LAMATA survey), informal modes ~90%% of all Lagos public-transit trips -- reporting modeled count only, no comparable target", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PassengerJourney rows=5905, ward-coherent (citizen home or work ward matches route corridor)=6396 (108.31%) -- target >=90%, guards against the random-hash CitizenId/TripId linkage this domain used before the 2026-08-01 rewrite", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "distinct Route/Stage place names=95, mapped in ref.LagosPlaceWardMap=95 (100.00%) -- target >=90%, guards against future route/stage edits silently introducing an unmapped place", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PassengerJourney rows=5905, date-effective ward-coherent (citizen home OR work ward AS OF the journey's own date matches route corridor)=5903 (99.97%) -- target >=90%, distinct from TR-R08's current-ward check", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/transport-certification.html" }, "vehicles": { "name": "Vehicles", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "vehicles", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/vehicles-certification.html" }, "fleet": { "name": "Fleet", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "fleet", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 16, "pass": 12, "fail": 0, "warn": 1, "info": 1, "na": 2, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "FLT-01", "name": "VehicleProfileCatalog / MaintenanceComponentCatalog / LicenseClassCatalog populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicle profiles=135, maintenance components=120, license classes=4", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-02", "name": "fleet.Driver populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "driver count=16469", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-03", "name": "Driver.EmployeeId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned driver rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-04", "name": "fleet.Vehicle populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicle count=6869", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-05", "name": "FuelConsumption.VehicleId / DriverId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned vehicle refs=0, orphaned driver refs=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-06", "name": "FuelConsumption.Liters/OdometerKm/CostAmount >= 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-07", "name": "Maintenance.VehicleId FK integrity", "status": "N/A", "detail": "fleet.Maintenance is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-08", "name": "Maintenance.CompletedUtc >= ScheduledUtc", "status": "N/A", "detail": "fleet.Maintenance is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-09", "name": "Vehicle.CreatedUtc not in the future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future-dated vehicles=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-10", "name": "FleetEventIndex populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "year rows=87", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-11", "name": "FleetEventIndex.Modifier within [0.10, 2.00]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "FuelConsumption rows where OdometerKm decreased vs. the same vehicle's prior reading: 0 of 1030350", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Average cost per liter: NGN 1174.84 (sourced band 400.00-1500.00 NGN)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct FuelType values: 2", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-R04", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "Maintenance events per vehicle: 0.00 (0 events / 6869 vehicles)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-R05", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Driver:Vehicle ratio: 2.40 (16469 drivers / 6869 vehicles) -- no cited real-world driver:vehicle-ratio benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 0.5-10.0 PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/fleet-certification.html" }, "roads": { "name": "Roads", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "roads", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/roads-certification.html" }, "postal-logistics": { "name": "Postal & Logistics", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "postal-logistics", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/postal-logistics-certification.html" }, "government": { "name": "Government", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "government", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/government-certification.html" }, "publicfinance": { "name": "Public Finance", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "publicfinance", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/publicfinance-certification.html" }, "emergency-services": { "name": "Emergency Services", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "emergency-services", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/emergency-services-certification.html" }, "socialprotection": { "name": "Social Protection", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "socialprotection", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/socialprotection-certification.html" }, "justice": { "name": "Justice", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "justice", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/justice-certification.html" }, "taxation": { "name": "Taxation", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "taxation", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/taxation-certification.html" }, "pensions": { "name": "Pensions", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "pensions", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/pensions-certification.html" }, "energy": { "name": "Energy", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "energy", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 18, "pass": 18, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "EN-H01", "name": "Provider populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "provider count=50", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H02", "name": "Facility populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "facility count=420", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H03", "name": "Asset populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "asset count=1320", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H04", "name": "Connection populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "connection count=5640692", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H05", "name": "Outage populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "outage count=410923", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H06", "name": "Consumption populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "consumption rows=61027320", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H07", "name": "Connection.HouseholdId FK integrity (CIP)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned household connections=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H08", "name": "Connection.BusinessId FK integrity (CIP)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned business connections=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H09", "name": "Connection.ConnectionDate within SeedEpoch-NowDate (TMS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "date violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H10", "name": "Outage.StartUtc within SeedEpoch-NowDate (TMS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "date violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H11", "name": "Outage.EstimatedRestorationUtc >= StartUtc (EDS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EDS violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H12", "name": "Consumption.ReadingPeriodEnd > ReadingPeriodStart (EDS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EDS violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H13", "name": "MaintenanceEvent.CompletedDate >= ScheduledDate (EDS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EDS violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rate=70.86% connected=4855049 total=6851571", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "GridSharePct sum=100.00% (expected ~100%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "active DISCOs=4 distinct outage types=22", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "readings with implausible per-kWh rate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=84.92% informal-housing connection rate=41.94%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/energy-certification.html" }, "power": { "name": "Power", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "power", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 19, "pass": 17, "fail": 0, "warn": 2, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "PWR-H01", "name": "Substation populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "substation count=26 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H02", "name": "TransmissionLine populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "line count=520 (min 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H03", "name": "Meter populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "meter count=500000 (min 1000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H04", "name": "Billing AmountLocal plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H05", "name": "Outage EndDatetime >= StartDatetime", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H06", "name": "DemandReading.FrequencyHz plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H07", "name": "Meter.InstallDate not in future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H08", "name": "Billing.BillingMonth in [1,12]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H09", "name": "Billing.PaidDate only set when Paid", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H10", "name": "DemandReading.SubstationId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H11", "name": "Every populated ward has an active meter", "status": "PASS", "detail": "uncovered populated wards=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H12", "name": "Outage.AffectedHouseholds non-negative", "status": "PASS", "detail": "negative rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "residential-class bills with implausible (>5000 kWh) monthly consumption=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R02", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "active household-linked meter coverage=4.74% (disclosed wide sanity band 10-95%, not an independently re-verified electrification target -- see CHANGELOG)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "outages lasting >720h (30 days)=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R04", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "substations with observed peak load >150% of design CapacityMVA=26", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bills dated before their own meter's InstallDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "readings outside the physically plausible [47,53] Hz envelope=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=5.00% informal-housing connection rate=2.48%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/power-certification.html" }, "gas": { "name": "Gas", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "gas", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 16, "pass": 16, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "GAS-H01", "name": "DistributionDepot populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "depot count=45 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H02", "name": "CylinderDispatch populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dispatch count=6000000 (min 10000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H03", "name": "Billing AmountLocal plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H04", "name": "Incident ResolvedDatetime >= IncidentDatetime", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H05", "name": "CylinderDispatch.CylinderSizeKG is a real standard size", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H06", "name": "Billing.BillingMonth in [1,12]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H07", "name": "Billing.PaidDate only set when Paid", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H08", "name": "PressureReading.PipelineId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H09", "name": "DistributionDepot.StorageCapacityM3 positive", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bills with implausible (>200kg) monthly consumption=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "reticulated Subscriber count (5000) as % of distinct cylinder-served households (3139497)=0.16% (must stay <=10% -- piped gas is real but niche in both cities, not a mass utility)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dispatches with implausible per-kg price=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "LOW/MEDIUM-severity incidents carrying a casualty count=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bills dated before their own subscriber's ConnectedDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "negative-pressure rows=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=0.05% informal-housing connection rate=0.02%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/gas-certification.html" }, "water": { "name": "Water", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "water", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 19, "pass": 17, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 2, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "WAT-H01", "name": "TreatmentPlant populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "plant count=96 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H02", "name": "Reservoir populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "reservoir count=300 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H03", "name": "Pipeline populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "pipeline count=3000 (min 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H04", "name": "Meter populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "meter count=698000 (min 1000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H05", "name": "Billing AmountLocal plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H06", "name": "Outage EndDatetime >= StartDatetime", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H07", "name": "FlowReading WaterLevelPct in [0,100]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H08", "name": "Meter.InstallDate not in future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H09", "name": "Billing.BillingMonth in [1,12]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H10", "name": "Billing.PaidDate only set when Paid", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H11", "name": "FlowReading.ReservoirId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H12", "name": "Every populated ward has an active meter", "status": "PASS", "detail": "uncovered populated wards=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "domestic/prepaid bills with implausible (>500 m3) monthly consumption=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "active household-linked meter coverage=6.61% (real active-connection research: Nairobi ~7-8%, Lagos ~5-44% depending on definition; band 3-20%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "reservoirs with CurrentLevelPct outside [0,100]=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R04", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Kenya-only check (validates against NCWSC-specific real capacity data)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bills dated before their own meter's InstallDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R06", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "measurement only -- billing collection rate=49.99% -- NOT the same concept as NCWSC's real ~54% non-revenue-water loss figure (produced-vs-billed volume is unmodeled)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=6.87% informal-housing connection rate=3.42%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/water-certification.html" }, "wastewater": { "name": "Wastewater", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "wastewater", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 16, "pass": 16, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "WW-H01", "name": "TreatmentPlant populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "plant count=40 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H02", "name": "SewerLine populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "line count=1000 (min 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H03", "name": "Connection populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "connection count=220000 (min 1000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H04", "name": "SewageLevy.AmountLocal plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H05", "name": "OverflowEvent.EndDatetime >= StartDatetime", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H06", "name": "SewageLevy.LevyMonth in [1,12]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H07", "name": "SewageLevy.PaidDate only set when Paid", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H08", "name": "InfluentReading.TreatmentPlantId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H09", "name": "TreatmentPlant.DesignCapacityMLD positive", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "levies with implausible (>20000) monthly amount=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Connection count (220000) as % of Household count (6851571)=3.21% (must stay <=30% -- sewer connection is real but niche in both cities, not universal)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "readings with EffluentBOD > InfluentBOD=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "LOW/MEDIUM-severity events carrying an affected-households count=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "levies dated before their own connection's ConnectedDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "implausible PHValue rows=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=1.89% informal-housing connection rate=0.96%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/wastewater-certification.html" }, "waste": { "name": "Solid Waste", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "solidwaste", "sourceShared": true, "result": { "total": 15, "pass": 14, "fail": 0, "warn": 1, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "SW-H01", "name": "CollectionZone populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "zone count=260 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H02", "name": "CollectionVehicle populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicle count=780 (min 20)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H03", "name": "CollectionRound populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "round count=200000 (min 1000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H04", "name": "LandfillDeposit.TippingFeeLocal positive", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H05", "name": "WasteComplaint.ResolutionDate >= ComplaintDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H06", "name": "CollectionVehicle.LastServiceDate not in future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H07", "name": "CollectionRound.WasteWeightKG only set for COMPLETED/PARTIAL", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H08", "name": "CollectionRound.CollectionVehicleId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H09", "name": "Every populated ward has a collection zone", "status": "WARN", "detail": "uncovered populated wards=26", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rounds with implausible (>15,000kg) single-trip weight=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "deposits citing more vehicles (VehicleCount) than exist citywide (780)=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rounds with implausible (>5,000) single-trip HouseholdsServed=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "deposits with implausible per-tonne rate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicles with an implausible (pre-1990) LastServiceDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "complaints taking >365 days to resolve=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/waste-certification.html" }, "telecom": { "name": "Telecom", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "telecom", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/telecom-certification.html" }, "iot": { "name": "IoT", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "iot", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 23, "pass": 23, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "IOT-01", "name": "DeviceTypeCatalog and SensorTypeCatalog populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "device types=7, sensor types=10", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-02", "name": "iot.Device populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "device count=2000", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-03", "name": "Sensor.DeviceId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned sensor rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-04", "name": "Every Device has at least one Sensor", "status": "PASS", "detail": "devices with zero sensors=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-05", "name": "SensorReading.ReadingValue >= 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-06", "name": "SensorReading.SensorId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned reading rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-07", "name": "Alert.ClearedUtc >= Alert.AlertUtc", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-08", "name": "Alert.Status consistent with ClearedUtc presence", "status": "PASS", "detail": "inconsistent rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-09", "name": "TelemetryStream.DeviceId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned stream rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-10", "name": "Device.WardId resolves against ref.Ward/ref.AdminUnit", "status": "PASS", "detail": "unresolved ward references=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "all reading values within physically plausible range for their SensorType", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "MotionDetected readings outside {0,1}: 0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "0 of 10 catalog sensor types have zero readings", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "worst single-status share within one SensorType=82.3%% (>=99%% would indicate Status is not independent of SensorType)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R04B", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "worst single-status share within one DeviceType=86.3%% (>=99%% would indicate Status is not independent of DeviceType)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R04C", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "worst single-status share within one Protocol=82.0%% (>=99%% would indicate Status is not independent of Protocol)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "sensors with >=1 alert=4680 of 6000 (78.0%%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "0 of 9 non-boolean sensor types show zero variation (constant reading value)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "city=LOS, ref warmest month=2 (observed avg=29.0C), ref coolest month=8 (observed avg=25.0C)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Alert rows where SensorId belongs to a different DeviceId than listed: 0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EnergyConsumption readings that decreased from the same sensor's prior reading: 0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "avg TrafficCameras/ward: above-average TrafficWeight=2.15, below-average=0.00", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EnergyConsumption sensors with >=1 alert=465 of 600", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/iot-certification.html" }, "environment": { "name": "Environment & Climate", "status": "partial", "sourceKey": "environment", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/environment-certification.html" }, "media-broadcasting": { "name": "Media & Broadcasting", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "media-broadcasting", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/lagos/domains/media-broadcasting-certification.html" } }, "nairobi": { "demographics": { "name": "Demographics", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "demographics", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 39, "pass": 38, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 1, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "DEMO-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dbo.Citizen volume: 5083540", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizen.DOB in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizen registration date must not precede date of birth (RegistrationDate < DOB): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Duplicate non-NULL Citizen.NationalId values: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Household.HeadCitizenId genuinely orphaned or unsynced (excludes legitimate foreign-national-headed NULLs): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HouseholdMember.CitizenId not found in dbo.Citizen: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Birth.BirthDate does not match Citizen.DOB for the same CitizenId: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Death.DeathDate <= own Citizen.DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Death.DeathDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Birth.MotherCitizenId under 12 years old at the recorded BirthDate: 0 of 689039 linked births", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Migration.MigrationDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Migration.MigrationDate before own Citizen.DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Not-dissolved households whose current CITIZEN Head has no matching Household.HeadCitizenId (excludes dissolved households and foreign-national heads -- see comment): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.PopulationSnapshot volume: 7395", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TwoParent=81906 (4.6%), SingleMother=439185 (24.5%), SingleFather=433363 (24.1%), ChildHeaded=0 (0.0%), Extended=116717 (6.5%), SinglePerson=523883 (29.2%), Other=199798 (11.1%), of 1794852 households -- 0 child-headed households of 1,794,852 current households (0.00%). ChildHeaded is a measurement only, not a hard-zero requirement -- see DEMO-C22/C23/C24/C27 for the actual structural invariants (all of which DO assert hard zero); a nonzero residual here reflects this database's own current lineage + placement model coverage, not a certification failure by itself.", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "% of 80+ birth cohort marked dead: 52.38% of 7569 (floor 15%, regression guard for the one-time-roll mortality bug)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with zero current household memberships: 0; citizens with 2+ current memberships (constraint violation): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with 2+ current Spouse-role members: 0; HouseholdMember rows with LeaveDate < JoinDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Dissolved households with current members: 0; empty-but-not-marked-dissolved households (informational, not failed on): 0; DissolutionDate/IsActive mismatches: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C20", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens whose Nth household transition starts before their (N-1)th one ended: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C21", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HouseholdMember rows with JoinDate before the member's own DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C22", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Minor Head with an eligible non-Lodger adult present in the same household: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C23", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with a real current member (citizen or foreign national) but no current Head: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C24", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with more than one current Head: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C25", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ChildCarePlacement rows with PlacementDate before the placed citizen's own DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C26", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Current HouseholdMember rows with neither CitizenId nor ForeignNationalId populated: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C27", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with more than one ACTIVE CHILD_HEADED placement: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C28", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households typed 'Single' with more than 1 current member: 0 (known pre-existing HouseholdType staleness, broader than Tier 4 -- see this check's own comment)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C29", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households whose ordinary (non-emergency) FORCED_ABSORPTION placements alone exceed the size-25 soft cap: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C30", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Households over the size-25 soft cap lacking an explicit FORCED_ABSORPTION_EMERGENCY placement reason: 0 of 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C31", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households over the group-concentration-8 soft cap without an explicit emergency placement reason: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Males per 100 females: 100.15 (M=2532608, F=2528907; real populations run ~103-107 at birth). Root cause of any deviation traced to cal.PopulationPyramid seed data itself, not just generator logic -- see CHANGELOG for detail; not fixed here (control-DB scope).", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Crude birth rate (trailing 12mo births per 1,000 living-population-proxy): 39.31 (199818 births; sourced band 20-40 per UN WPP 2022 Kenya~28.3/Nigeria~34.2)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Crude death rate (trailing 12mo deaths per 1,000 living-population-proxy): 6.93 (35243 deaths; sourced band 3-15 per UN WPP 2022 Kenya~5.4/Nigeria~11.4)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct CauseCategory values: 6; largest bucket: 34.98% of 396917 deaths", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct MigrationType values represented: 3 of 3 (In/Out/Internal), across 1000000 rows", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Migration In=300446 vs Out=199706 (both cities are real net-in-migration urban destinations; In should be >= Out)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with DOB in the older half of the observed date range: 131661 vs younger half: 4951879 (a growing population should skew toward the younger/more-recent half)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Mean live household size: 2.64 (4741272 live members / 1794852 households; sourced band 1.5-7.0 per KNBS 2019 Nairobi~2.9 / Nigeria NDHS~4.8-5.0)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/demographics-certification.html" }, "household": { "name": "Households", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "demographics", "sourceShared": true, "result": { "total": 39, "pass": 38, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 1, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "DEMO-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dbo.Citizen volume: 5083540", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizen.DOB in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizen registration date must not precede date of birth (RegistrationDate < DOB): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Duplicate non-NULL Citizen.NationalId values: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Household.HeadCitizenId genuinely orphaned or unsynced (excludes legitimate foreign-national-headed NULLs): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HouseholdMember.CitizenId not found in dbo.Citizen: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Birth.BirthDate does not match Citizen.DOB for the same CitizenId: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Death.DeathDate <= own Citizen.DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Death.DeathDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Birth.MotherCitizenId under 12 years old at the recorded BirthDate: 0 of 689039 linked births", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Migration.MigrationDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.Migration.MigrationDate before own Citizen.DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Not-dissolved households whose current CITIZEN Head has no matching Household.HeadCitizenId (excludes dissolved households and foreign-national heads -- see comment): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "demographics.PopulationSnapshot volume: 7395", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TwoParent=81906 (4.6%), SingleMother=439185 (24.5%), SingleFather=433363 (24.1%), ChildHeaded=0 (0.0%), Extended=116717 (6.5%), SinglePerson=523883 (29.2%), Other=199798 (11.1%), of 1794852 households -- 0 child-headed households of 1,794,852 current households (0.00%). ChildHeaded is a measurement only, not a hard-zero requirement -- see DEMO-C22/C23/C24/C27 for the actual structural invariants (all of which DO assert hard zero); a nonzero residual here reflects this database's own current lineage + placement model coverage, not a certification failure by itself.", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "% of 80+ birth cohort marked dead: 52.38% of 7569 (floor 15%, regression guard for the one-time-roll mortality bug)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with zero current household memberships: 0; citizens with 2+ current memberships (constraint violation): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with 2+ current Spouse-role members: 0; HouseholdMember rows with LeaveDate < JoinDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Dissolved households with current members: 0; empty-but-not-marked-dissolved households (informational, not failed on): 0; DissolutionDate/IsActive mismatches: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C20", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens whose Nth household transition starts before their (N-1)th one ended: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C21", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HouseholdMember rows with JoinDate before the member's own DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C22", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Minor Head with an eligible non-Lodger adult present in the same household: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C23", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with a real current member (citizen or foreign national) but no current Head: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C24", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households with more than one current Head: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C25", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ChildCarePlacement rows with PlacementDate before the placed citizen's own DOB: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C26", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Current HouseholdMember rows with neither CitizenId nor ForeignNationalId populated: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C27", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with more than one ACTIVE CHILD_HEADED placement: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C28", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households typed 'Single' with more than 1 current member: 0 (known pre-existing HouseholdType staleness, broader than Tier 4 -- see this check's own comment)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C29", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households whose ordinary (non-emergency) FORCED_ABSORPTION placements alone exceed the size-25 soft cap: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C30", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Households over the size-25 soft cap lacking an explicit FORCED_ABSORPTION_EMERGENCY placement reason: 0 of 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-C31", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Households over the group-concentration-8 soft cap without an explicit emergency placement reason: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Males per 100 females: 100.15 (M=2532608, F=2528907; real populations run ~103-107 at birth). Root cause of any deviation traced to cal.PopulationPyramid seed data itself, not just generator logic -- see CHANGELOG for detail; not fixed here (control-DB scope).", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Crude birth rate (trailing 12mo births per 1,000 living-population-proxy): 39.31 (199818 births; sourced band 20-40 per UN WPP 2022 Kenya~28.3/Nigeria~34.2)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Crude death rate (trailing 12mo deaths per 1,000 living-population-proxy): 6.93 (35243 deaths; sourced band 3-15 per UN WPP 2022 Kenya~5.4/Nigeria~11.4)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct CauseCategory values: 6; largest bucket: 34.98% of 396917 deaths", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct MigrationType values represented: 3 of 3 (In/Out/Internal), across 1000000 rows", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Migration In=300446 vs Out=199706 (both cities are real net-in-migration urban destinations; In should be >= Out)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with DOB in the older half of the observed date range: 131661 vs younger half: 4951879 (a growing population should skew toward the younger/more-recent half)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "DEMO-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Mean live household size: 2.64 (4741272 live members / 1794852 households; sourced band 1.5-7.0 per KNBS 2019 Nairobi~2.9 / Nigeria NDHS~4.8-5.0)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/household-certification.html" }, "education": { "name": "Education", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "education", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 22, "pass": 19, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 3, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "EDU-H01", "name": "Schools populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "school count=2060 (min 100)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H02", "name": "Enrollment.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H03", "name": "Teacher.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H04", "name": "Student age at enrollment plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-band rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H05", "name": "EnrollmentDate within SeedEpoch..NowDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H06", "name": "Exam scores in [0,100]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H07", "name": "Bursary amount > 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "non-positive rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H08", "name": "Teacher licence-number uniqueness", "status": "PASS", "detail": "duplicate licence numbers=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H09", "name": "TertiaryEnrollment end year >= start year", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H10", "name": "Every populated ward has an active school", "status": "PASS", "detail": "uncovered populated wards=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H11", "name": "Attendance date >= Enrollment start", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violating rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H12", "name": "TertiaryInstitution.WardId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-H13", "name": "StudentPopulation.UniversityId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "enrollment rows with age outside their GradeLevel's plausible band=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "employed 25-34yr-olds with an Enrollment record=100.00% (KNBS NEMIS cites 82% school-enrollment ages 6-17; NBF R-03 ref=80%, band 50-100%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R03", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Nigeria-only check (Lagos LSMOE-2022 age-band citation has no Kenya equivalent yet)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "max deviation from EDU-CAL-002 tier pyramid (5/15/30/50%)=0.42pp (band <=10pp)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rows with an implausible program length for their ProgramType=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-R06", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "measurement only -- pupil:teacher ratio=13.90:1 -- no cited real pupil-teacher-ratio target exists for either city yet", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-C01", "name": "Historical academic-year coverage", "status": "N/A", "detail": "expected years (1960-2026)=67, generated years=67 (100.00%), earliest=1960, latest=2026, fully-generated=66, partially-generated=1 (the single oldest generated year, 1960, is the only one that can be partial -- see check header)", "source": "11_coverage_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-C02", "name": "Grade/progression coverage completeness", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Expected grade-year cells=1072, SATISFIED=1070, EXHAUSTED_VARIANCE=2, INCOMPLETE=0, EXHAUSTED_ANOMALY=0, missing terminal-secondary cells=0 (exhaustion state from RunId 7E8B6B2C-5E1E-4E4B-B832-7D2E01BA4A70)", "source": "11_coverage_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EDU-C02b", "name": "Examination/TertiaryEnrollment dependency guards", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Terminal-secondary Enrollment=2466309 -> Examination terminal rows=92419; tertiary-eligible Examination rows=113693 -> TertiaryEnrollment rows=16777", "source": "11_coverage_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/education-certification.html" }, "employment": { "name": "Employment", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "employment", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 49, "pass": 46, "fail": 0, "warn": 2, "info": 1, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "EMP-E01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Employer volume: 10002", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Department volume: 68576 (expected >= 4x Employer)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract volume: 99508", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SelfEmployment volume: 917922", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Payroll volume: 542519", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.CitizenId FK violations: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SelfEmployment.CitizenId FK violations: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows for deceased citizens: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.StartDate outside [DOB+18, NowDate]: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.EndDate < StartDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.IsActive/Termination-row mismatches: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with both active Contract and active SelfEmployment: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Payroll rows with GrossAmount<=0 or NetAmount<0: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Termination.TerminationDate < Contract.StartDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct SectorCode in Employer: 12 (expected >= 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EmploymentEventIndex populated: 87 years", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SelfEmployment.StartDate outside [DOB+18, NowDate]: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.StartDate after own citizen DeathDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "% of citizens who died at age 25+ with any employment history (Contract or SelfEmployment): 32.17% of 211496 (floor 25%, regression guard for the blanket demographics.Death exclusion pattern)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E20", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Payroll pay-period after Contract.EndDate month: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E21", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Payroll pay-period after citizen DeathDate month: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E22", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PensionContribution period after Contract.EndDate month: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E23", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PensionContribution period after citizen DeathDate month: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E24", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract.DepartmentId belonging to a different EmployerId: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E25", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows whose Department slot is not an active mapped choice for JobTitleId: 0 (0 historical/inactive rows preserved as a disclosed pre-Phase-E department-taxonomy artifact, not counted toward this check)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E26", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "JobTitleCatalog titles with no active JobTitleDepartmentMap row: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E27", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract rows whose own non-NULL JobTitleId has no currently-active department mapping: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E28", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "City/Sector cells where active Deployment total exceeds active Participation PAY_WAGE total: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E29", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows whose Department is not applicable for its Employer's Sector+Size template: 0 (0 historical/inactive rows reported separately, non-gating)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E31", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows whose current-role effective date (ContractRoleHistory/PromotionHistory/StartDate) is still below SeniorityProgressionRule's age floor for their current SeniorityLevel: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E32", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows holding a credentialed title with no matching completed TertiaryEnrollment: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E33", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows whose title requires a professional license with no matching active ProfessionalLicense: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E34", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows holding an active ProfessionalLicense not in that title's allowed profession set: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E35", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Nairobi job families proven materially reachable by H0's shadow diagnostic (AGRO/EDUJ/ENGG/FNAC/HRES) with zero live active representation: 0 (excluded from this gate, no family-level manifest row at this grain -- have real live representation via other title-level evidence instead: EDUJ,ENGG,FNAC,HRES)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E36", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contract rows below the applicable StatutoryWageFloor: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E37", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Within-family seniority coherence (min-vs-max populated level, both >=10 contracts, 10% overlap tolerance): 0 of 6 tested families materially inverted", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E38", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Within-occupation EmployerSize salary ratio: avg=1.1458 max=1.2122", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E39", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Largest exact-value point mass in active GrossMonthlyLocal: 3 of 80146", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E40", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Contract/Payroll gross mismatches=0, Payroll arithmetic mismatches=0, Payroll/Pension mismatches=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E41", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active Contracts under a LIQUIDATED employer (should be 0, closed by usp_CloseLiquidatedEmployerContracts): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-E42", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Active Contracts under a DORMANT/SUSPENDED employer (informational -- no auto-termination policy defined yet): 12841", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-EDU-001", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "Avg JobTitleCatalog.SeniorityLevel: degree-holders=2.12, no education record at all=2.18 (EMP-00007 causal link)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-EDU-002", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "Of 2620 active SeniorityLevel>=4 contracts, 1.11% held by a citizen with a COMPLETED tertiary program (sourced floor 40%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-EDU-003", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Formal-employment rate: no-education-record=4.51% (n=2041), completed-tertiary=7.33% (n=4187)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct EmploymentType values: 3 across 99508 contracts", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active contracts below the minimum wage (KES 15,201/month, Kenya 2022 gazette): 0.00% of 80146 (sourced ceiling 15%% -- some sub-minimum-wage employment is realistic, a majority would not be)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "GrossMonthlyLocal range: min=18401.17, avg=71257.16, max=368671.83", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with both an active Contract and a SelfEmployment record: 0 of 917922 self-employed", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EMP-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct JobTitleId values in use: 36 of 54 cataloged (JobTitleCatalog is under-utilized by the generator -- disclosed, not fixed this pass)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/employment-certification.html" }, "health": { "name": "Health", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "health", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 94, "pass": 82, "fail": 5, "warn": 2, "info": 5, "na": 0, "failChecks": [ { "code": "HLT-REL01", "detail": "Scoped to ENCOUNTER-type prescriptions only -- REFILL-type has no single anchoring visit by design." }, { "code": "HLT-REL02", "detail": "Population-level General-Surgery/Orthopedic draws (SourceICD10Code IS NULL) are out of scope by design." }, { "code": "HLT-REL03", "detail": "A general-screening lab with no condition-driven indication would legitimately fail this -- interpret alongside population share, not as an absolute gate, if it ever fires on real data." }, { "code": "HLT-REL05", "detail": "This is the known, previously-disclosed Emergency/MCH facility-capability gap (COMMERCIAL_RELEASE_SCOPING.md) -- expected to genuinely FAIL on first real data, not a new finding." }, { "code": "HLT-REL08", "detail": "Only checks allergies identified BEFORE the prescribing visit -- a later-discovered allergy does not retroactively indict an earlier, reasonable prescription." } ], "checks": [ { "code": "HLT-H01", "name": "Facilities populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "facility count=1252 (min 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H02", "name": "Patient.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned patient rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H03", "name": "One patient record per citizen", "status": "PASS", "detail": "duplicate citizen-patients=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H04", "name": "Visit dates within SeedEpoch–NowDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "date violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H05", "name": "Discharge date >= Admission date", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H06", "name": "Prescription Quantity and DurationDays > 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H07", "name": "ClinicalStaff.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned staff rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H08", "name": "Maternity DeliveryDate within valid window", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H09", "name": "Each citizen ward has at least one facility", "status": "PASS", "detail": "wards without facility=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H10", "name": "BedOccupancy.OccupiedBeds <= TotalBeds", "status": "PASS", "detail": "over-occupied rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H11", "name": "Patient.RegistrationDate >= Citizen.DOB", "status": "PASS", "detail": "registrations before birth=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H12", "name": "Visit.VisitDate >= Citizen.DOB", "status": "PASS", "detail": "visits before birth=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H13", "name": "Visit.VisitDate >= Patient.RegistrationDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "visits before registration=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H14", "name": "MaternityRecord mother age at delivery in [12,55]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "implausible mother age at delivery=0 of 89317", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H15", "name": "Visit.VisitDate <= own citizen DeathDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "visits after death=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H16", "name": "Health foundation ready (Facility/ClinicalStaff/BedOccupancy populated, no orphaned BedOccupancy.FacilityId)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Facility=1252, ClinicalStaff=88102, BedOccupancy=593269, orphaned BedOccupancy.FacilityId=0 (run NRBDB/LGSDB_01_HealthFoundation if any is 0)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H17", "name": "Condition.ResolvedDate <= NowDate (never a phantom future resolution)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future-resolved conditions=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H18", "name": "Prescription.CreatedUtc within 7 days of NowDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future-dated prescriptions=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H19", "name": "Claim.SubmittedDate within 7 days of NowDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future-dated claims=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H20", "name": "Visit.VisitDate <= own citizen DepartureDate while non-resident", "status": "PASS", "detail": "visits after departure=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-H21", "name": "No non-resident citizen with a NULL DepartureDate (HLT-H20 presence-check dependency)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "non-resident citizens with NULL DepartureDate=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R01", "name": "Population coverage (Patients / Citizens) -- expected band ~50-85% under the eligibility-gated model", "status": "PASS", "detail": "patients=3437155 of 5083540 citizens (67.61%) -- HLT-00007's 100%-registry policy superseded by HLT-00026; see health/CHANGELOG.md", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R02", "name": "Utilization coverage (Patients with >=1 visit / Patients)", "status": "INFO", "detail": "active patients=2901788 of 3437155 (84.42%) -- generator samples ~2% of PatientId for visit history (documented volume-control, not a realism target); see health/CHANGELOG.md Phase 3 for the proposed risk-weighted replacement", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R03", "name": "Visit distribution shape (P90>P50, P99>P90, Max>=P99 -- catches a flat/artificial distribution)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "P50=3 P90=11 P99=21 Max=57", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R04", "name": "Age utilization correlation (avg visits 65+ > avg visits 18-44)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "avg visits 65+=9.607 vs 18-44=4.717", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R05", "name": "Chronic disease correlation (avg visits diabetic > non-diabetic)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "avg visits diabetic=9.453 vs non-diabetic=4.011", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R06", "name": "Temporal integrity cross-reference (duplicates HLT-H15 in core cert)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "visits after death=0 -- informational duplicate, core/09_certification.sql is authoritative", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R07", "name": "Clinical plausibility cross-reference (vitals within physiological range)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "implausible vital-sign rows=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R08", "name": "Heavy-utilizer tail exists (not artificially capped)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "patients >20 visits=31795, >50=14, >100=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R09", "name": "Annual per-capita visit rate vs. real-world benchmark (year 2025)", "status": "WARN", "detail": "observed=0.2684 visits/capita/year (1221316 visits / 4549837 living citizens), plausible band=[0.30-2.50] per cited Nairobi FY2017/18 outpatient study + intra-Kenya county range -- known cause: the 2% PatientId volume-control sample (R02), not a data-quality defect; see health/CHANGELOG.md HLT-00008", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R10", "name": "Eligibility channel mix (Insurance/MaternalCare/ChildImmunization/IllnessEncounter all present + non-degenerate, Insurance smallest of those four; HistoricalDiseaseEvent informational)", "status": "WARN", "detail": "HistoricalDiseaseEvent=0, Insurance=0, MaternalCare=1414147, ChildImmunization=943899, IllnessEncounter=1072140 of 3437155 eligible citizens", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R11", "name": "Enrollment-year distribution spans the full simulation window with visible real event-year bumps", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EnrollmentYear range=[1940-2026], canary year=2017 count=171447 vs neighbor avg=86866.8", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-R12", "name": "Historical disease sampling matches its scaled real-number target within rounding tolerance", "status": "INFO", "detail": "no literally-rated events for this city yet -- see 01c_patient_eligibility.sql's audit", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DS01", "name": "Every non-initial state has a valid transition edge from its predecessor", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDiseaseState rows=6149358", "source": "19b_disease_state_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DS02", "name": "State-date sequence never regresses within one (Patient, Disease)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDiseaseState rows=6149358", "source": "19b_disease_state_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DS03", "name": "StateDate >= own Condition.OnsetDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDiseaseState rows=6149358", "source": "19b_disease_state_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DS04", "name": "StateDate <= own citizen DeathDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDiseaseState rows=6149358", "source": "19b_disease_state_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DS05", "name": "No two different states for the same (Patient, Disease) on the same StateDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDiseaseState rows=6149358", "source": "19b_disease_state_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DS06", "name": "Every PatientDiseaseState row resolves to exactly one health.Condition row", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDiseaseState rows=6149358", "source": "19b_disease_state_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DS07", "name": "PatientDiseaseState only ever contains diseases registered in DiseaseStateManifest", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDiseaseState rows=6149358", "source": "19b_disease_state_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DS08", "name": "Diagnosis/Condition untouched by this proc (verified by code inspection)", "status": "INFO", "detail": "usp_GenerateHealthDiseaseState only INSERTs into health.PatientDiseaseState -- no UPDATE/DELETE against Diagnosis/Condition exists in this file.", "source": "19b_disease_state_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-CP01", "name": "CarePlan without indication (resolvable Condition) = 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "CarePlan rows=2386756", "source": "20b_careplan_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-CP02", "name": "CarePlan.StartDate >= own Condition.OnsetDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "CarePlan rows=2386756", "source": "20b_careplan_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-CP03", "name": "CarePlanActivity.ScheduledDate within [CarePlan.StartDate, EndDate]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "CarePlan rows=2386756", "source": "20b_careplan_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-CP04", "name": "CareTeamMember.StaffId is an active, real ClinicalStaff row", "status": "PASS", "detail": "CarePlan rows=2386756", "source": "20b_careplan_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-CP05", "name": "CareTeamMember staff belongs to the same Facility as the diagnosing Visit", "status": "PASS", "detail": "CarePlan rows=2386756", "source": "20b_careplan_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-CP06", "name": "No active CarePlan against an already-resolved (closed) Condition", "status": "PASS", "detail": "CarePlan rows=2386756", "source": "20b_careplan_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-REL01", "name": "Diagnosis<->Medication: ENCOUNTER-type Prescription's medication is plausible for at least one same-visit Diagnosis", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "Scoped to ENCOUNTER-type prescriptions only -- REFILL-type has no single anchoring visit by design.", "source": "23_relationship_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-REL02", "name": "Diagnosis<->Procedure: diagnosis-driven ProcedureEvent.SourceICD10Code has a real DiagnosisProcedureMap entry", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "Population-level General-Surgery/Orthopedic draws (SourceICD10Code IS NULL) are out of scope by design.", "source": "23_relationship_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-REL03", "name": "Diagnosis<->Lab: LabResult.PanelCode is a real ConditionLabPanelMap entry for at least one of the patient's own Conditions", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "A general-screening lab with no condition-driven indication would legitimately fail this -- interpret alongside population share, not as an absolute gate, if it ever fires on real data.", "source": "23_relationship_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-REL04", "name": "Visit<->Staff: AttendingStaffId, when populated, is a real active ClinicalStaff row at the same Facility", "status": "PASS", "detail": "AttendingStaffId is nullable by design -- unpopulated rows are not a violation.", "source": "23_relationship_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-REL05", "name": "Visit<->Facility capability: Emergency/Maternity-ANC visits only occur at a Facility with the matching HasEmergency/HasMaternity flag", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "This is the known, previously-disclosed Emergency/MCH facility-capability gap (COMMERCIAL_RELEASE_SCOPING.md) -- expected to genuinely FAIL on first real data, not a new finding.", "source": "23_relationship_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-REL06", "name": "Condition<->Prescription: every REFILL-type Prescription's medication maps to its own still-open Condition", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Scoped to REFILL-type only -- the corrected generator population, not the disclosed pre-fix 157.66M-row historical population (see CHANGELOG HLT-00040/health/core/06_growth.sql header).", "source": "23_relationship_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-REL07", "name": "Immunization<->VaccineManifest: VaccineCode resolves to a real, age-eligible VaccineManifest row", "status": "PASS", "detail": "No enforced FK exists between these two tables today -- this check is what actually proves the relationship, not a formality restating a constraint.", "source": "23_relationship_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-REL08", "name": "Allergy<->Medication: no patient holds an active Prescription for a medication they are recorded allergic to", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "Only checks allergies identified BEFORE the prescribing visit -- a later-discovered allergy does not retroactively indict an earlier, reasonable prescription.", "source": "23_relationship_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-REL09", "name": "Claim<->Clinical event: ServiceRefId resolves to a real Prescription/ProcedureEvent matching its own ServiceType", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ServiceRefId is deliberately not FK-enforced (two possible parent tables per this table's own header comment) -- this is the data-level proof a schema constraint cannot provide here.", "source": "23_relationship_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-IMG01", "name": "ImagingStudy.PerformedDate >= OrderedDate (already a CHECK constraint -- defense in depth)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ImagingStudy rows=330097", "source": "21b_imaging_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-IMG02", "name": "ImagingResult.ReportedDate >= own ImagingStudy.PerformedDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ImagingStudy rows=330097", "source": "21b_imaging_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-IMG03", "name": "ImagingStudy.PerformedDate >= own source Visit.VisitDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ImagingStudy rows=330097", "source": "21b_imaging_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-IMG04", "name": "ImagingStudy.PerformedDate <= own citizen DeathDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ImagingStudy rows=330097", "source": "21b_imaging_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-IMG05", "name": "ImagingStudy.FacilityId meets the study's own MinFacilityLevel", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ImagingStudy rows=330097", "source": "21b_imaging_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-IMG06", "name": "Every ImagingResult resolves to exactly one real ImagingStudy", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ImagingStudy rows=330097", "source": "21b_imaging_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DEV01", "name": "Every device has a real clinical indication (SourceProcedureId or SourceICD10Code -- already a CHECK constraint)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDevice rows=35164", "source": "22b_medical_device_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DEV02", "name": "StartDate <= own citizen DeathDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDevice rows=35164", "source": "22b_medical_device_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DEV03", "name": "Procedure-sourced device StartDate matches its own ProcedureEvent.ProcedureDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDevice rows=35164", "source": "22b_medical_device_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DEV04", "name": "Every STENT/AVF-ACCESS device traces to a real qualifying ProcedureEvent", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PatientDevice rows=35164", "source": "22b_medical_device_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM01", "name": "Symptom.OnsetDate <= own Condition.OnsetDate (symptom precedes/coincides with diagnosis)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Symptom rows=2067140", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM02", "name": "Symptom.OnsetDate >= own Patient citizen DOB", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Symptom rows=2067140", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM03", "name": "Symptom.OnsetDate <= own citizen DeathDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Symptom rows=2067140", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM04", "name": "Every Symptom.ConditionId resolves to exactly one real Condition (already a FK -- defense in depth)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Symptom rows=2067140", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM05", "name": "Health Complete V1 symptom vocabulary is exactly 39 distinct bounded concepts", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SymptomCatalog rows=39; distinct standard codes=39; required=39/39", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM06", "name": "Characteristic symptom mappings cover priority disease families", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Required mappings present=16/16", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM07", "name": "Health Complete V1 symptom map has exact governed cardinality", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Mappings=167/167; mapped diseases=53/53", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM08", "name": "Every DiagnosisSymptomMap row has a valid ResolutionMode and duration bounds (defense in depth vs CK_HDSM_Duration/CK_HDSM_ResolutionMode)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DiagnosisSymptomMap rows=167", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM09", "name": "Symptom.ResolvedDate >= Symptom.OnsetDate (defense in depth vs CK_HSymptom_Resolved)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Symptom rows=2067140", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM10", "name": "Symptom.ResolvedDate never in the future and never after own citizen DeathDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Symptom rows=2067140; NowDate=2026-07-02", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM11", "name": "No EPISODIC/PERSISTENT symptom remains unresolved past its own deterministic candidate resolution date", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Symptom rows=2067140", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM12", "name": "Every Symptom.ResolvedDate matches its disease-symptom resolution policy, recomputed deterministically", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Symptom rows=2067140", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM13", "name": "Realism (INFO): observed symptom duration distribution, ResolutionMode=EPISODIC", "status": "INFO", "detail": "n=629517; median=4d; P95=13d", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SYM13", "name": "Realism (INFO): observed symptom duration distribution, ResolutionMode=PERSISTENT", "status": "INFO", "detail": "n=1056630; median=56d; P95=109d", "source": "25b_symptom_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SPEC01", "name": "Every LabResult resolves to exactly one real Specimen (once backfilled)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "LabResult rows=19255553, Specimen rows=5361230", "source": "26b_specimen_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SPEC02", "name": "Specimen.CollectionDate <= own LabResult.ResultDate for every linked result", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Specimen rows=5361230", "source": "26b_specimen_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SPEC03", "name": "Specimen.CollectionDate >= own source Visit.VisitDate (when VisitId present)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Specimen rows=5361230", "source": "26b_specimen_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SPEC04", "name": "Specimen.FacilityId is a real active facility (FK -- defense in depth)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Specimen rows=5361230", "source": "26b_specimen_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-SPEC05", "name": "Coverage: every non-null LabResult (post-backfill) has a SpecimenId", "status": "PASS", "detail": "LabResult rows without SpecimenId=0", "source": "26b_specimen_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-RXD01", "name": "Every MedicationDispense resolves to exactly one real Prescription (already a FK -- defense in depth)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "MedicationDispense rows=60125269", "source": "27b_medication_dispense_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-RXD02", "name": "MedicationDispense only exists for Prescription.IsDispensed=1", "status": "PASS", "detail": "MedicationDispense rows=60125269", "source": "27b_medication_dispense_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-RXD03", "name": "MedicationDispense.DispensedDate >= own source Visit.VisitDate (when VisitId present)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "MedicationDispense rows=60125269", "source": "27b_medication_dispense_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-RXD04", "name": "Coverage: every IsDispensed=1 Prescription has a MedicationDispense row", "status": "PASS", "detail": "IsDispensed=1 Prescription rows=60125269", "source": "27b_medication_dispense_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DR01", "name": "Laboratory report IssuedDate >= own Specimen.CollectionDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DiagnosticReport rows=5691327", "source": "28b_diagnostic_report_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DR02", "name": "Imaging report IssuedDate = own ImagingResult.ReportedDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DiagnosticReport rows=5691327", "source": "28b_diagnostic_report_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DR03", "name": "Category/source-column pairing is exclusive (already a CHECK constraint -- defense in depth)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DiagnosticReport rows=5691327", "source": "28b_diagnostic_report_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DR04", "name": "Coverage: every Specimen with >=1 LabResult has a DiagnosticReport", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DiagnosticReport rows=5691327", "source": "28b_diagnostic_report_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HLT-DR05", "name": "Coverage: every ImagingStudy with an ImagingResult has a DiagnosticReport", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DiagnosticReport rows=5691327", "source": "28b_diagnostic_report_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/health-certification.html" }, "hr": { "name": "HR", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "hr", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 18, "pass": 15, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 3, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "HR-H01", "name": "employment.Job populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "job count=262 (min 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H02", "name": "employment.Job: MinSalaryLocal <= MaxSalaryLocal", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H03", "name": "employment.Job: All salaries > 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "zero/negative salary rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H04", "name": "employment.Job: JobCode unique", "status": "PASS", "detail": "duplicate JobCodes=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H05", "name": "employment.Job: GradeLevel in valid set", "status": "PASS", "detail": "invalid grade rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H06", "name": "employment.Job: Sector in valid set", "status": "PASS", "detail": "invalid sector rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H07", "name": "employment.Job: At least 10 distinct sectors", "status": "PASS", "detail": "distinct sectors=25 (min 10)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H08", "name": "employment.Job: Entry-level jobs present", "status": "PASS", "detail": "entry-level job count=46 (min 10)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H09", "name": "hr.Employee populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "employee count=86,690", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H10", "name": "hr.Employee.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned employee rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H11", "name": "hr.Payroll: NetAmount <= GrossAmount", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H12", "name": "hr.SocialInsuranceScheme: Health and Pension schemes seeded", "status": "PASS", "detail": "health schemes=1, pension schemes=1", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H13", "name": "hr.GradeTierMap covers all GradeBands used by hr.Position", "status": "PASS", "detail": "unmapped grade bands=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H14", "name": "hr.Payroll: no rows after Employee.SeparationDateUtc", "status": "PASS", "detail": "payroll rows after separation=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H15", "name": "hr.Payroll: deduction pass evidence (NetAmount < GrossAmount)", "status": "N/A", "detail": "hr.Payroll is empty -- generator has not run yet in this environment", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H16", "name": "hr.Payroll rows after the employee's own citizen DeathDate", "status": "N/A", "detail": "hr.Payroll is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-H17", "name": "% of citizens who died at age 25+ with any hr.Employee history", "status": "PASS", "detail": "measurement only (HR participation is a small public-sector subset, not universal): 0 of 211496", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HR-R00", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "hr.Payroll is empty -- this city's generator has not run yet", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/hr-certification.html" }, "civil-registration": { "name": "Civil Registration", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "civil-registration", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/civil-registration-certification.html" }, "economy": { "name": "Economy", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "economy", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/economy-certification.html" }, "business": { "name": "Business", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "business", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 17, "pass": 16, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 1, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "BIZ-01", "name": "business.SectorCrosswalk populated (16 canonical sectors)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rows=16", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-02", "name": "dbo.Business populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "business count=215384", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-03", "name": "BusinessCode uniqueness", "status": "PASS", "detail": "duplicate codes=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-04", "name": "Business.SectorCode within converged CHECK enum", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-05", "name": "Business.SectorCode resolves in business.SectorCrosswalk", "status": "PASS", "detail": "unmapped=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-06", "name": "Business.OwnerCitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned owner refs=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-07", "name": "Business.RegistrationDate not in the future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future-dated rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-08", "name": "Business.EmployeeCount within its BusinessSize band", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-09", "name": "transport.Operator.BusinessId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned operator refs=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-10", "name": "No non-liquidated business owned by a deceased citizen", "status": "PASS", "detail": "non-liquidated businesses with deceased owner=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-11", "name": "No owner exceeds the per-owner business cap", "status": "PASS", "detail": "worst single-owner business count=5, cap=5", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "RegistrationDate before OwnerCitizenId.DOB: 0; owner under 18 at registration: 0 of 128261 owned businesses. Real root cause was usp_ReweightForeignOriginBusinessOwnership reassigning owners with no DOB/age eligibility check, not stale pre-fix data as BUS-00002 originally assumed -- fixed + backfilled + guarded by a DOB/Death trigger on dbo.Business, see CHANGELOG BUS-00003.", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "MICRO=55.08% SMALL=29.77% MEDIUM=10.06% (sourced target 55/30/10 per CAC/NBS 2023 Lagos State Business Survey, +-5pp band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct SectorCode values: 16 of 16; largest sector: 22.00% of 215384 businesses", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EmployeeCount > 1 but IsEmployer = 0: 0 of 215384 businesses", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R05", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Foreign-owned businesses: 8402 (3.90%) of 215384 -- no cited city-level benchmark, reporting only", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "BIZ-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ACTIVE businesses: 79.94% of 215384 (some DORMANT/SUSPENDED/LIQUIDATED expected, not 100% active)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/business-certification.html" }, "banking": { "name": "Banking", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "banking", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/banking-certification.html" }, "finance": { "name": "Finance", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "finance", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 22, "pass": 19, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 3, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "FIN-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxType volume: 8", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BudgetHead volume: 16", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAccount orphaned Citizen/Business FKs: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAccount rows violating exactly-one-owner: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAssessment orphaned Account/Type FKs: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAssessment negative amounts / DueDate < AssessmentDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAssessment orphaned ParcelId FKs: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxPayment orphaned FK / non-positive amount: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BudgetAllocation orphaned FK / negative amount: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BudgetExpenditure orphaned FK / non-positive amount: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BudgetAllocation rows with cumulative overspend: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Directorate volume: 10", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Department orphaned DirectorateId FKs: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DepartmentWorkforceWeight sum: 10000 (expected 10000bp)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAssessment rows with invalid Status: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxPayment.PaymentDate before its Assessment.AssessmentDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Active TaxAccount under a LIQUIDATED business (should be 0): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R01", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Tax assessments with at least one payment: 73.05% of 14984360 -- no cited real-world tax-compliance-rate benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 30-98% PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R02", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Budget utilization (BudgetExpenditure / BudgetAllocation.ApprovedAmount): 86.47% -- no cited real-world budget-utilization-rate benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 50-100% PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct TaxTypeId values on TaxAssessment: 4", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TaxAccount by CitizenId: 5083540; by BusinessId: 215384 of 5298924", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FIN-R05", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Reversed payments: 2.00% of 10945556 -- no cited real-world payment-reversal-rate benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 0-10% PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/finance-certification.html" }, "insurance": { "name": "Insurance", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "insurance", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 21, "pass": 17, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 1, "na": 3, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "INS-01", "name": "InsuranceCompany populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "company count=15", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-02", "name": "Policy catalog populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "policy count=28", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-03", "name": "Coverage.CitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned coverage rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-04", "name": "Claim amounts non-negative", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-05", "name": "Policy.LaunchDate >= InsuranceCompany.EstablishedDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-06", "name": "Coverage.StartUtc >= Policy.LaunchDate (INS-HIST-001)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-07", "name": "Coverage.StartUtc >= ops.Config SeedEpoch", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-08", "name": "Claim.SubmittedUtc >= Coverage.StartUtc", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-09", "name": "Claim.ProcessedUtc >= Claim.SubmittedUtc", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-10", "name": "Claim.IncidentDate <= Claim.SubmittedUtc", "status": "N/A", "detail": "no claims populate IncidentDate in this environment", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-11", "name": "PremiumPayment: Amount >= 0 and (Coverage,Year,Month) unique", "status": "PASS", "detail": "negative-amount rows=0, duplicate coverage-month rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-12", "name": "Claim: FraudFlag set iff OriginalClaimAmount set", "status": "PASS", "detail": "inconsistent rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-13", "name": "Beneficiary.SharePct in [0,100]", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.Beneficiary not present or empty (nigeria extension not active)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-14", "name": "AccidentClaim.AccidentId FK integrity", "status": "N/A", "detail": "insurance.AccidentClaim empty or transport.Accident not yet deployed", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-15", "name": "PremiumPayment/Claim dated after the covered citizen's own DeathDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "post-death premium rows=0, post-death claim rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct Coverage.AcquisitionType values: 4", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Citizens with active Coverage: 28.93% of 5083540 (sourced band 5-60%%, Kenya NHIF/SHIF and Nigeria NHIS coverage estimates)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct Claim.Status values: 4 across 1236777 claims", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-R04", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Claim approval rate: 80.08% of 1236777 claims -- no cited real-world claim-approval-rate benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 50-95% PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Denied/Partial claims missing a RejectionReasonCode: 0 of 184706", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "INS-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Claims where ApprovedAmount > ClaimAmount: 0 of 1236777", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/insurance-certification.html" }, "commerce": { "name": "Commerce", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "commerce", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/commerce-certification.html" }, "hospitality": { "name": "Hospitality", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "hospitality", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/hospitality-certification.html" }, "manufacturing": { "name": "Manufacturing", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "manufacturing", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/manufacturing-certification.html" }, "agriculture": { "name": "Agriculture", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "agriculture", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/agriculture-certification.html" }, "housing": { "name": "Housing", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "housing", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 21, "pass": 20, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 1, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "housing-H01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HousingUnit volume (400000 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Tenancy volume (1794852 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "RentPayment.AmountLocal all > 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Tenancy.StartDate within [SeedEpoch, NowDate]", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "RentPayment.PeriodMonth in [1,12]", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Eviction.NoticeDate >= Tenancy.StartDate", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Inspection.Outcome all valid catalog values", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "every ward with a citizen has >=1 housing unit", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "AffordableHousingProject unit-count consistency (Occupied<=Allocated<=Target)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Tenancy.MonthlyRentLocal all >= 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HousingType diversity (8 distinct values)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TenureType diversity (6 distinct values)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "HousingEventIndex populated (87 years)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "chronology invariants hold (unit/tenancy/inspection/payment ordering)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Inspection.InspectionCode all valid catalog values", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "housing-H16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "no open Tenancy for an all-deceased household", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Occupied units (open tenancy): 69.52% of 400000 housing units", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Rental tenancies: 896416 vs Owner: 359015 of 1794852 (both cities are real renter-majority urban markets; rental should be >= owner)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R03", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "Evictions: 1.39% of 1794852 tenancies -- no cited real-world eviction-rate benchmark yet, not graded (was an uncited 0-25% PASS/WARN band)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct Inspection.Outcome values: 5 across 800000 inspections", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "HSG-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "AffordableHousingProject allocation: 66.25% of target units across 200 projects", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/housing-certification.html" }, "land": { "name": "Land", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "land", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 20, "pass": 17, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 1, "na": 2, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "LND-L01", "name": "Parcels populated (min 50/ward)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "parcels=200,000 (min 4,250 = 85 wards x 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L02", "name": "Parcel.CitizenOwnerId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned citizen parcels=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L03", "name": "Parcel.BusinessOwnerId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned business parcels=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L04", "name": "No parcel has both CitizenOwnerId and BusinessOwnerId", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dual-owner parcels=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L05", "name": "Parcel.PlotSizeSqM > 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L06", "name": "Parcel.MarketValueLocal >= 0 (where populated)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L07", "name": "Each parcel has an InitialGrant ownership record", "status": "N/A", "detail": "this jurisdiction's TransferReasonCatalog has no InitialGrant reason -- not applicable", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L08", "name": "OwnershipHistory.TransactionDate within epoch–NowDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0 [1940-01-01 – 2026-07-02]", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L09", "name": "LandTaxBill.BillAmountLocal > 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-L10", "name": "Ward coverage >= 95% of wards have parcels", "status": "PASS", "detail": "wards with parcels=85 of 85", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Parcels still owned by a deceased CitizenOwnerId: 0 of 200000", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct LandUseType values: 5; largest: 50.00% of 200000 parcels", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Correlation(ward IncomeMultiplier, avg parcel MarketValueLocal): 1.002 (directional only -- wealthier wards should show higher land values)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "IsEncumbered=1: 7.95% of 200000 parcels", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "IsServiced rate: Freehold/Leasehold=89.97% vs Informal/Disputed=30.07% (formal tenure should be more serviced)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "OwnershipHistory rows with EndDate before TransactionDate: 0 of 24815", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R07", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "This city's IsEncumbered rate (see LND-R04) should be compared against the other city's own run -- both should show a non-zero, non-trivial rate, not one flat at 0%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Correlation(PlotSizeSqM, MarketValueLocal): 0.34993 across 200000 parcels (directional only -- bigger plots should be worth more, sublinearly)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R09", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "Most common TransferValueLocal/MarketValueLocal ratio (4dp) accounts for N/A% of 0 Sale rows (a real negotiated-price distribution should not concentrate on one exact ratio)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "LND-R10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Owner-lives-in-same-ward rate: 39.147% of 120000 individually-owned parcels vs random baseline 1.176% (1/85 wards) -- should be clearly above baseline, not statistically indistinguishable from it", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/land-certification.html" }, "construction": { "name": "Construction", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "construction", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 25, "pass": 25, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "construction-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ProjectSector seeded (2 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ProjectType seeded (51 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit volume (200000 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit.PermitFeeLocal all >= 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit temporal order (ApprovalDate >= ApplicationDate)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project volume (100002 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project CompletedUnits within [0, PlannedUnits]", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SiteInspection volume (400000 rows)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit.ContractorBusinessId FK integrity", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SiteInspection PASS rate plausible (50.0%)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project PlannedEndDate > StartDate", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit approval rate plausible (50.0%)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "every phased project has exactly 4 phases", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "ConstructionEventIndex populated (87 years)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "OccupancyCertificate only issued against Completed projects", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "SiteInspection.InspectionDate not before linked Project.StartDate/Permit.ApprovalDate", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit.ContractorBusinessId sector coherence (SectorCode=CONSTRUCTION)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project.ContractorBusinessId sector coherence (SectorCode=CONSTRUCTION)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "BuildingPermit contractor existed by ApplicationDate (RegistrationDate <= ApplicationDate)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "construction-C20", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "construction.Project contractor existed by StartDate (RegistrationDate <= StartDate)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Completed projects finishing after PlannedEndDate: 73.97% of 40002 (real construction/infrastructure projects run late far more often than not -- 0% or near-0% is a generator artifact, not realism)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Avg ActualCostLocal/BudgetLocal ratio: 1.100; % over budget: 68.62% (sourced band: ratio 1.0-1.3, >=50% over-budget, per global infrastructure cost-overrun literature)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct ProjectTypeId values used: 51; largest single type: 2.00% of 100002 projects", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct construction.Project.Status values: 4 of up to 4 (Planned/Active/Completed/Suspended)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "CON-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Distinct SiteInspection.Outcome values: 4 across 400000 inspections", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/construction-certification.html" }, "infrastructure": { "name": "Infrastructure", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "infrastructure", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/infrastructure-certification.html" }, "urban-planning": { "name": "Urban Planning", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "urban-planning", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/urban-planning-certification.html" }, "real-estate": { "name": "Real Estate", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "real-estate", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/real-estate-certification.html" }, "transport": { "name": "Transport", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "transport", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 42, "pass": 40, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 1, "na": 1, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "TR-C01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Operator volume: 200", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Route volume: 200", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle volume: 11364", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip volume: 98033028", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "AccidentParticipant.Role values outside catalog (casing regression guard): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle.OperatorId FK violations: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip.ArrivalUtc < DepartureUtc: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle assigned to a Route owned by a different Operator: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle.AcquiredDate in the future: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Ticket.DueDate < IssuedDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Accident.ReportedToPolice=1 with no PoliceReportNumber: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C12", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "AccidentClaim.AccidentId FK violations: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C13", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DriverLicense.ExpiryDate <= IssuedDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C14", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Fare.BoardingStageId = AlightingStageId: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C15", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip.DepartureUtc after driver's own DeathDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C16", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TransportEventIndex populated: 87 years", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C17", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip.PassengerCount > Vehicle.SeatCapacity: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C18", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Vehicle.YearOfManufacture > YEAR(AcquiredDate): 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C19", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "DriverLicense.IssuedDate before holder's 18th birthday: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C20", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "LicenseRenewal.RenewalDate before original license IssuedDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C21", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "TicketPayment.AmountPaidLocal > Ticket.FineAmountLocal: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-C22", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Trip.DepartureUtc after Vehicle.RetiredDate: 0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV01", "name": "PrivateVehicle populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicle count=223586 (min 1000)", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV02", "name": "OwnerType coverage (need >=5 of 7)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "distinct OwnerType=7", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV03", "name": "Owner-shape integrity (exactly one owner link per OwnerType)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV04", "name": "OwnerCitizenId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned rows=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV05", "name": "OwnerBusinessId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned rows=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV06", "name": "OwnerForeignNationalId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned rows=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV07", "name": "PlateNumber uniqueness", "status": "PASS", "detail": "duplicate plate groups=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV08", "name": "YearOfManufacture in [1980, NowYear]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV09", "name": "RegistrationDate <= NowDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TRP-PV10", "name": "Second-vehicle rate plausible (2%-25% of individual owners)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rate=11.94% (19986 of 167319 individual owners)", "source": "09b_private_vehicle_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "year=2025 trips/active-vehicle/day=5.617 (4255206 trips / 2074 active vehicles) -- design target 6-10/day per kenya/06_growth.sql, corroborated by Lagos danfo field research (~9.2/day)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R02", "name": "", "status": "INFO", "detail": "active in 2025=2074 of 11364 ever-registered (2436 not yet retired as of NowDate) -- no fixed target, fleet turnover expected", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "avg occupancy%% peak=77.54 midday=39.87 off-peak=14.84", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "peak target=[65,95] got=77.5; midday target=[30,55] got=39.9; off-peak target=[10,25] got=14.8", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "min=6 avg=2051.69 max=2190 trips/vehicle in 2025", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "revenue-with-no-passengers=0, passengers-with-no-revenue=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "modeled fleet=11364, real-world Nairobi matatu/PSV estimate=[11000-20000] (multiple independent estimates) -- closing this gap is an architecture/volume decision, not a quick fix: Operator/Route/Vehicle/Trip/Passenger all scale together", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PassengerJourney rows=1632, ward-coherent (citizen home or work ward matches route corridor)=1582 (96.94%) -- target >=90%, guards against the random-hash CitizenId/TripId linkage this domain used before the 2026-08-01 rewrite", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "distinct Route/Stage place names=182, mapped in ref.NairobiPlaceWardMap=182 (100.00%) -- target >=90%, guards against future route/stage edits silently introducing an unmapped place", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "TR-R10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "PassengerJourney rows=1632, date-effective ward-coherent (citizen home OR work ward AS OF the journey's own date matches route corridor)=1594 (97.67%) -- target >=90%, distinct from TR-R08's current-ward check: catches period-segmentation/date-matching defects that TR-R08's current-state view can't see", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/transport-certification.html" }, "vehicles": { "name": "Vehicles", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "vehicles", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/vehicles-certification.html" }, "fleet": { "name": "Fleet", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "fleet", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 12, "pass": 9, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 3, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "FLT-01", "name": "VehicleProfileCatalog / MaintenanceComponentCatalog / LicenseClassCatalog populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicle profiles=135, maintenance components=120, license classes=4", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-02", "name": "fleet.Driver populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "driver count=1199", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-03", "name": "Driver.EmployeeId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned driver rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-04", "name": "fleet.Vehicle populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicle count=500", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-05", "name": "FuelConsumption.VehicleId / DriverId FK integrity", "status": "N/A", "detail": "fleet.FuelConsumption is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-06", "name": "FuelConsumption.Liters/OdometerKm/CostAmount >= 0", "status": "N/A", "detail": "fleet.FuelConsumption is empty", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-07", "name": "Maintenance.VehicleId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned maintenance rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-08", "name": "Maintenance.CompletedUtc >= ScheduledUtc", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-09", "name": "Vehicle.CreatedUtc not in the future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future-dated vehicles=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-10", "name": "FleetEventIndex populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "year rows=87", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-11", "name": "FleetEventIndex.Modifier within [0.10, 2.00]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "FLT-R00", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "fleet.FuelConsumption is empty -- this city's generator has not run yet", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/fleet-certification.html" }, "roads": { "name": "Roads", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "roads", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/roads-certification.html" }, "postal-logistics": { "name": "Postal & Logistics", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "postal-logistics", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/postal-logistics-certification.html" }, "government": { "name": "Government", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "government", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/government-certification.html" }, "publicfinance": { "name": "Public Finance", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "publicfinance", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/publicfinance-certification.html" }, "emergency-services": { "name": "Emergency Services", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "emergency-services", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/emergency-services-certification.html" }, "socialprotection": { "name": "Social Protection", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "socialprotection", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/socialprotection-certification.html" }, "justice": { "name": "Justice", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "justice", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/justice-certification.html" }, "taxation": { "name": "Taxation", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "taxation", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/taxation-certification.html" }, "pensions": { "name": "Pensions", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "pensions", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/pensions-certification.html" }, "energy": { "name": "Energy", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "energy", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 18, "pass": 18, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "EN-H01", "name": "Provider populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "provider count=25", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H02", "name": "Facility populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "facility count=222", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H03", "name": "Asset populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "asset count=855", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H04", "name": "Connection populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "connection count=1564913", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H05", "name": "Outage populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "outage count=134180", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H06", "name": "Consumption populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "consumption rows=16929444", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H07", "name": "Connection.HouseholdId FK integrity (CIP)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned household connections=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H08", "name": "Connection.BusinessId FK integrity (CIP)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned business connections=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H09", "name": "Connection.ConnectionDate within SeedEpoch-NowDate (TMS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "date violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H10", "name": "Outage.StartUtc within SeedEpoch-NowDate (TMS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "date violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H11", "name": "Outage.EstimatedRestorationUtc >= StartUtc (EDS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EDS violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H12", "name": "Consumption.ReadingPeriodEnd > ReadingPeriodStart (EDS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EDS violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-H13", "name": "MaintenanceEvent.CompletedDate >= ScheduledDate (EDS)", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EDS violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rate=75.25% connected=1350628 total=1794852", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "GridSharePct sum=100.00% (expected ~100%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "active DISCOs=1 distinct outage types=10", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "readings with implausible per-kWh rate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "EN-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=85.01% informal-housing connection rate=41.91%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/energy-certification.html" }, "power": { "name": "Power", "status": "documentation", "sourceKey": "power", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 19, "pass": 18, "fail": 0, "warn": 1, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "PWR-H01", "name": "Substation populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "substation count=80 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H02", "name": "TransmissionLine populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "line count=1200 (min 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H03", "name": "Meter populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "meter count=400000 (min 1000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H04", "name": "Billing AmountLocal plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H05", "name": "Outage EndDatetime >= StartDatetime", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H06", "name": "DemandReading.FrequencyHz plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H07", "name": "Meter.InstallDate not in future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H08", "name": "Billing.BillingMonth in [1,12]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H09", "name": "Billing.PaidDate only set when Paid", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H10", "name": "DemandReading.SubstationId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H11", "name": "Every populated ward has an active meter", "status": "PASS", "detail": "uncovered populated wards=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-H12", "name": "Outage.AffectedHouseholds non-negative", "status": "PASS", "detail": "negative rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "residential-class bills with implausible (>5000 kWh) monthly consumption=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "active household-linked meter coverage=15.35% (disclosed wide sanity band 10-95%, not an independently re-verified electrification target -- see CHANGELOG)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "outages lasting >720h (30 days)=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R04", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "substations with observed peak load >150% of design CapacityMVA=68", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bills dated before their own meter's InstallDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "readings outside the physically plausible [47,53] Hz envelope=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "PWR-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=14.42% informal-housing connection rate=7.17%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/power-certification.html" }, "gas": { "name": "Gas", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "gas", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 16, "pass": 16, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "GAS-H01", "name": "DistributionDepot populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "depot count=30 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H02", "name": "CylinderDispatch populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dispatch count=4000000 (min 10000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H03", "name": "Billing AmountLocal plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H04", "name": "Incident ResolvedDatetime >= IncidentDatetime", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H05", "name": "CylinderDispatch.CylinderSizeKG is a real standard size", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H06", "name": "Billing.BillingMonth in [1,12]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H07", "name": "Billing.PaidDate only set when Paid", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H08", "name": "PressureReading.PipelineId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-H09", "name": "DistributionDepot.StorageCapacityM3 positive", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bills with implausible (>200kg) monthly consumption=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "reticulated Subscriber count (3000) as % of distinct cylinder-served households (1418052)=0.21% (must stay <=10% -- piped gas is real but niche in both cities, not a mass utility)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "dispatches with implausible per-kg price=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "LOW/MEDIUM-severity incidents carrying a casualty count=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bills dated before their own subscriber's ConnectedDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "negative-pressure rows=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "GAS-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=0.12% informal-housing connection rate=0.04%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/gas-certification.html" }, "water": { "name": "Water", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "water", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 19, "pass": 17, "fail": 0, "warn": 1, "info": 0, "na": 1, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "WAT-H01", "name": "TreatmentPlant populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "plant count=55 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H02", "name": "Reservoir populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "reservoir count=202 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H03", "name": "Pipeline populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "pipeline count=1000 (min 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H04", "name": "Meter populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "meter count=190000 (min 1000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H05", "name": "Billing AmountLocal plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H06", "name": "Outage EndDatetime >= StartDatetime", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H07", "name": "FlowReading WaterLevelPct in [0,100]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H08", "name": "Meter.InstallDate not in future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H09", "name": "Billing.BillingMonth in [1,12]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H10", "name": "Billing.PaidDate only set when Paid", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H11", "name": "FlowReading.ReservoirId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-H12", "name": "Every populated ward has an active meter", "status": "PASS", "detail": "uncovered populated wards=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "domestic/prepaid bills with implausible (>500 m3) monthly consumption=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "active household-linked meter coverage=7.29% (real active-connection research: Nairobi ~7-8%, Lagos ~5-44% depending on definition; band 3-20%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "reservoirs with CurrentLevelPct outside [0,100]=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R04", "name": "", "status": "WARN", "detail": "plants with observed output >150% of design CapacityMLD=9", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bills dated before their own meter's InstallDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R06", "name": "", "status": "N/A", "detail": "measurement only -- billing collection rate=49.99% -- NOT the same concept as NCWSC's real ~54% non-revenue-water loss figure (produced-vs-billed volume is unmodeled)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WAT-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=7.11% informal-housing connection rate=3.58%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/water-certification.html" }, "wastewater": { "name": "Wastewater", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "wastewater", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 16, "pass": 16, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "WW-H01", "name": "TreatmentPlant populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "plant count=30 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H02", "name": "SewerLine populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "line count=800 (min 50)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H03", "name": "Connection populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "connection count=250000 (min 1000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H04", "name": "SewageLevy.AmountLocal plausible", "status": "PASS", "detail": "out-of-range=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H05", "name": "OverflowEvent.EndDatetime >= StartDatetime", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H06", "name": "SewageLevy.LevyMonth in [1,12]", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H07", "name": "SewageLevy.PaidDate only set when Paid", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H08", "name": "InfluentReading.TreatmentPlantId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-H09", "name": "TreatmentPlant.DesignCapacityMLD positive", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "levies with implausible (>20000) monthly amount=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Connection count (250000) as % of Household count (1794852)=13.93% (must stay <=30% -- sewer connection is real but niche in both cities, not universal)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "readings with EffluentBOD > InfluentBOD=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "LOW/MEDIUM-severity events carrying an affected-households count=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "levies dated before their own connection's ConnectedDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "implausible PHValue rows=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "WW-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "formal-housing connection rate=8.00% informal-housing connection rate=3.98%", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/wastewater-certification.html" }, "waste": { "name": "Solid Waste", "status": "sample", "sourceKey": "solidwaste", "sourceShared": true, "result": { "total": 15, "pass": 14, "fail": 0, "warn": 1, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "SW-H01", "name": "CollectionZone populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "zone count=50 (min 5)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H02", "name": "CollectionVehicle populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicle count=200 (min 20)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H03", "name": "CollectionRound populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "round count=150000 (min 1000)", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H04", "name": "LandfillDeposit.TippingFeeLocal positive", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H05", "name": "WasteComplaint.ResolutionDate >= ComplaintDate", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H06", "name": "CollectionVehicle.LastServiceDate not in future", "status": "PASS", "detail": "future rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H07", "name": "CollectionRound.WasteWeightKG only set for COMPLETED/PARTIAL", "status": "PASS", "detail": "bad rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H08", "name": "CollectionRound.CollectionVehicleId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphans=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-H09", "name": "Every populated ward has a collection zone", "status": "WARN", "detail": "uncovered populated wards=40", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rounds with implausible (>15,000kg) single-trip weight=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "deposits citing more vehicles (VehicleCount) than exist citywide (200)=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "rounds with implausible (>5,000) single-trip HouseholdsServed=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "deposits with implausible per-tonne rate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "vehicles with an implausible (pre-1990) LastServiceDate=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "SW-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "complaints taking >365 days to resolve=0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/waste-certification.html" }, "telecom": { "name": "Telecom", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "telecom", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/telecom-certification.html" }, "iot": { "name": "IoT", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "iot", "sourceShared": false, "result": { "total": 23, "pass": 23, "fail": 0, "warn": 0, "info": 0, "na": 0, "failChecks": {}, "checks": [ { "code": "IOT-01", "name": "DeviceTypeCatalog and SensorTypeCatalog populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "device types=7, sensor types=10", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-02", "name": "iot.Device populated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "device count=500", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-03", "name": "Sensor.DeviceId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned sensor rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-04", "name": "Every Device has at least one Sensor", "status": "PASS", "detail": "devices with zero sensors=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-05", "name": "SensorReading.ReadingValue >= 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-06", "name": "SensorReading.SensorId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned reading rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-07", "name": "Alert.ClearedUtc >= Alert.AlertUtc", "status": "PASS", "detail": "violations=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-08", "name": "Alert.Status consistent with ClearedUtc presence", "status": "PASS", "detail": "inconsistent rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-09", "name": "TelemetryStream.DeviceId FK integrity", "status": "PASS", "detail": "orphaned stream rows=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-10", "name": "Device.WardId resolves against ref.Ward/ref.AdminUnit", "status": "PASS", "detail": "unresolved ward references=0", "source": "09_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R01", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "all reading values within physically plausible range for their SensorType", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R02", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "MotionDetected readings outside {0,1}: 0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R03", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "0 of 10 catalog sensor types have zero readings", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R04", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "worst single-status share within one SensorType=84.7%% (>=99%% would indicate Status is not independent of SensorType)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R04B", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "worst single-status share within one DeviceType=90.0%% (>=99%% would indicate Status is not independent of DeviceType)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R04C", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "worst single-status share within one Protocol=86.0%% (>=99%% would indicate Status is not independent of Protocol)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R05", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "sensors with >=1 alert=1161 of 1500 (77.4%%)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R06", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "0 of 9 non-boolean sensor types show zero variation (constant reading value)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R07", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "city=NRB, ref warmest month=2 (observed avg=19.6C), ref coolest month=7 (observed avg=15.0C)", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R08", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "Alert rows where SensorId belongs to a different DeviceId than listed: 0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R09", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EnergyConsumption readings that decreased from the same sensor's prior reading: 0", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R10", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "avg TrafficCameras/ward: above-average TrafficWeight=2.27, below-average=1.37", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" }, { "code": "IOT-R11", "name": "", "status": "PASS", "detail": "EnergyConsumption sensors with >=1 alert=116 of 150", "source": "10_realism_certification.sql" } ] }, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/iot-certification.html" }, "environment": { "name": "Environment & Climate", "status": "partial", "sourceKey": "environment", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/environment-certification.html" }, "media-broadcasting": { "name": "Media & Broadcasting", "status": "planned", "sourceKey": "media-broadcasting", "sourceShared": false, "result": null, "report": "cities/nairobi/domains/media-broadcasting-certification.html" } } }, "benchmarks": { "lagos": { "source": "cities/lagos/audits/event-ablation-dashboard.html", "rows": [ [ "FP2020 Commitment / Renewed Family Planning Push", "Confirmed explanatory signal" ], [ "Boko Haram Insurgency Displacement", "Confirmed explanatory signal" ], [ "Structural Adjustment Programme (Nigeria)", "Confirmed explanatory signal" ], [ "National Policy on Population for Development", "Confirmed explanatory signal" ], [ "Nigerian Oil Boom", "No confirmed signal in available benchmark window" ], [ "COVID-19 Pandemic (Nigeria)", "No confirmed signal in available benchmark window" ], [ "Nigerian Civil War (Biafra)", "No confirmed signal in available benchmark window" ], [ "Fertility Decline Stall/Rebound", "Recalibration review candidate" ] ], "scope": "Published event-ablation categories. Numerical error scores and calibration parameters are not disclosed in these public reports." }, "nairobi": { "source": "cities/nairobi/audits/event-ablation-dashboard.html", "rows": [ [ "Fertility Decline Resumption", "Confirmed explanatory signal" ], [ "Family Planning Programme Intensification", "Confirmed explanatory signal" ], [ "East Africa Drought", "Confirmed explanatory signal" ], [ "Asian Financial Crisis Impact", "Confirmed explanatory signal" ], [ "2007-08 Post-Election Violence", "No confirmed signal in available benchmark window" ], [ "COVID-19 Pandemic", "No confirmed signal in available benchmark window" ], [ "Structural Adjustment Programme", "No confirmed signal in available benchmark window" ], [ "Fertility Decline Stall", "Recalibration review candidate" ], [ "Post-COVID Economic Recovery", "Recalibration review candidate" ], [ "National Family Planning Programme Launch", "Recalibration review candidate" ] ], "scope": "Published event-ablation categories. Numerical error scores and calibration parameters are not disclosed in these public reports." } } }